8/10
A surprisingly subversive satire which every soldier could recognise
5 September 2013
Warning: Spoilers
Rather amazing that such a film could be made in this period, when memories of the Second World War were still fresh in everyone's minds and National Service was still in full swing. I think it works partly because virtually the entire nation had served in uniform and easily recognised each and every character as someone they'd served with. The idea that it is dedicated to all those who got away with the various scams against authority is astonishingly daring for the time but probably touches a common chord in British society in which the war had led to such great social upheaval and questioning of the traditional class system.

What an AMAZING cast who would dominated British film and TV comedy for the next half a century. Ian Carmichael is beyond perfect as the epitome of the 'chinless wonder', a hapless upper class twit obviously destined for the officer class (where he could do less harm?) but stuck as a private and adopted by his contemporaries who take pity upon him. Richard Attenborough great as the spiv, amazing to think this is the man who later made Ghandi! William Hartnell playing the tough NCO he would specialise in before becoming Dr Who, Terry Thomas terrific as ever as the pompous Major, a man who was simply born to play roguish authority figures. John Le Meusier too as the psychiatrist and an unbilled Christopher Lee playing the German General's aide.

Very much of its' time but you can see its' appeal.
9 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

Recently Viewed