Wow there are such a lot of moaners about doctor who. Yes the science is bad but please remember this is a show about aliens and time travel. This story was exciting thought provoking and a great character piece. Yes the doctor is out of character but that's the point it's a turning point for 12. I personally love how he's not a big grinning coward like 10 was who was to afraid to kill anyone even if it meant innocent people suffered. 12 is real and does what needs to be done. As for him leaving he has done it before. Think of hungry earth cold blood he made Amy make the decision about the silurians it's exactly the same thing here.
The other negative things said about Clara. Well the companions have always been the main character since 1963 so why all of a sudden is it a problem. The doctor worked everything out himself in this episode yes Clara made the choice but it couldn't have been done without the doctor. He was always watching as as soon as Clara stopped the bomb he landed showing he was watching what was happening. He was showing how much he cared about humanity by letting them choose their fate.
this is an amazing episode one or the best of an amazing season
The other negative things said about Clara. Well the companions have always been the main character since 1963 so why all of a sudden is it a problem. The doctor worked everything out himself in this episode yes Clara made the choice but it couldn't have been done without the doctor. He was always watching as as soon as Clara stopped the bomb he landed showing he was watching what was happening. He was showing how much he cared about humanity by letting them choose their fate.
this is an amazing episode one or the best of an amazing season