Rating: 8/10
Watched on March 27th 2024 (first watch)
Format: Home TV
An amazing portray of Egypt's 1950s and specifically the Cairo train Station.
The film touches on many topics like poverty, jealousy, simplicity, and revenge.
Hind Rustum shines as the pretty girl who sells drinks in a train station and plays the women that everyone looks at because of her beauty. On the other hand, Youssef Chahine (who's also the director of the film) as the poor Qinawi who sells newspapers and hopes for a better life with the women he's into, was an unfortunate acting choice. He's very dull and most importantly does not represent poverty, revenge, and jealousy that Qinawi suffers from accurately. Moreover, his character needed more in depth view and perhaps more dialogues but in my opinion that still wouldn't have saved or changed anything as someome else should've played the role of Qinawi.
The film's short runtime was a great choice because the story itself doesn't require any longer runtime as it would've resulted in many boring sequences. The film's second half really picks up and focuses more on the sensitive topics as it makes the story very interesting and leads to an ending that fits with every character.
An amazing portray of Egypt's 1950s and specifically the Cairo train Station.
The film touches on many topics like poverty, jealousy, simplicity, and revenge.
Hind Rustum shines as the pretty girl who sells drinks in a train station and plays the women that everyone looks at because of her beauty. On the other hand, Youssef Chahine (who's also the director of the film) as the poor Qinawi who sells newspapers and hopes for a better life with the women he's into, was an unfortunate acting choice. He's very dull and most importantly does not represent poverty, revenge, and jealousy that Qinawi suffers from accurately. Moreover, his character needed more in depth view and perhaps more dialogues but in my opinion that still wouldn't have saved or changed anything as someome else should've played the role of Qinawi.
The film's short runtime was a great choice because the story itself doesn't require any longer runtime as it would've resulted in many boring sequences. The film's second half really picks up and focuses more on the sensitive topics as it makes the story very interesting and leads to an ending that fits with every character.