Momma Berry's Veggie Soda Shop, on the Veggie side of town has been awarded every year for its amazing "soyshakes" and meatless meals. This year, however, Berry, the owner's daughter (and the awkward and shy one of the group) has been receiving a large quantity of meat baskets every night, baskets which she has had to hide from everyone in town. It all comes to worse, when the secret admirer turns out to be the mysterious boy working in the meat shop across the street, on the meat-eating side of town; and when a milk bottle finds its way into the veggie shop creating the feared "meatshake".