The Strange Case of Dr. Manning (1957) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
5 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
British film thriller promise too much !
niels-45 July 2005
Dr. Manning, a successful doctor, married to a rich woman, is called out in the middle of the night to take care of a patient. Dr. Manning never returns from his visit and soon after his wife receives a ransom letter requesting five thousand pounds. From then on Mrs. Manning (Greta Gynt) is taken on a roller coaster ride trying to catch up with the kidnappers to deliver the money. But each delivery is a failure and soon it seems like everybody is inn on the secret which only complicates the matter. Mr. Manning is soon found killed and the killer is at large. The only way to catch him is if Mrs. Manning becomes the bait. She has heard the killers voice several times over the telephone. The newspaper press almost ruins the case by reporting disclosed information that makes the killer a danger to be around.

Towards the end of the movie there is a cat and mouse chase between the police and the killer. Marked ransom money soon appear and that leads us to the killer. A suspect that is not involved in the film in any ways, so you will never guess who he/she is up to the last moment. The motive for the killing of Dr. Manning is valid enough.

An American detective, played by Ron Randell, is there to solve the mystery, he collaborates with The Scotland Yard. But this case could really manage without him. I assume the American actor, Ron Randell, was mostly there to lure the audience to attend the film once it was distributed in The US. Through out the film Randell is there to assure us that the mystery will soon be resolved, annoying at times.

"The Strange Case of Dr. Manning" aka "Morning Call" is fine to watch, but kind of "much to do about nothing". It is not a dull film, it is fast moving, has many inn and outdoor scenes, but there are too many characters involved. Director Arthur Crabtree does his best to pull off this story, but it never becomes a "film-noir" triumph, the script is too ordinary for that, unfortunately.

Lead actress, Greta Gynt, in one of her last films before she ended her twenty year old film career. She is very restrained in her role as Mrs. Manning, the script allows her only to worry. She is very much apart of the film and should have been focused on during the cat and mouse chase between police and murder. Instead Ms. Gynt walks on to the scene after the whole affair is over. A brilliant actress who knows well how to portray suspense should have been at hand. That is the big crime of this film :) The End !
14 out of 14 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
The last gasp of Republic British
malcolmgsw28 January 2019
Warning: Spoilers
In 1956 Republic made a big profit. However because the demand for their films was on the slide Yates closed the company down in 1958. They made some decent films in Britain with well known American actors,Randall being the exception. This film for me breaks one of the basic rules,the killer is a character who only comes in five minutes before the end so no chance of guessing who is the killer.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
There are many sides to the shape of crime.
mark.waltz1 May 2021
Warning: Spoilers
There are the victims. There are the law enforcement officers involved, the press, well-meaning neighbors causing unintentional problems and of course the criminals. This British film, coming at the end of Republic's reign as the top B movie studio, stars Greta Gynt as a loving wife whose husband, a well-known doctor in the neighborhood, is kidnapped and held for ransom. In spite of being aided by law enforcement, Gynt decides to deal with a kidnappers directly and incidents beyond her control prevents her from getting the ransom money to them. But there's a twist that she did not see coming, and now she must ate law enforcement in capturing those responsible.

While this could have just a direct a crime that has been covered many times in movies, it takes other aspects in expanding the story. Friends and neighbors try to help (and threaten to make the situation worse), a lady of the evening claims to have seen the man she believes responsible, and neighborhood kids get involved where they shouldn't. When detective Ron Randall basically tells these nosy busy bodies to stay out of it, he gets a big round of applause.

The kidnapping is not only a threat to its victim but to Gynt as well, making it one of many women in jeopardy thrillers of the 1940's and 50's. She's a good actress and certainly beautiful and is deserving of sympathy even though she doesn't make all the right decisions. This will keep you engrossed and it's exciting how they resolve everything, bringing it to an intense conclusion.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
It Really is a Stinker
alice-enland30 May 2021
Warning: Spoilers
It's a kidnapping of a society doctor who is married to a socialite wife. His wife is genuinely interested in recovering her husband but the police and the press keep getting in the way. Those aspects make us wonder if this isn't also a tale for current times.
0 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
A regular kidnapping drama going all wrong as usual
clanciai1 March 2021
Greta Gynt was always a striking appearance in the films in which she acted, and she is the ornament of this film, as beautiful as ever, while her role is limited to the very worrying rich wife of the doctor who gets kidnapped for no obvious reason. Although a great actress, she never reached prominence as a star, although she always acted well. The sordid business here, the bleak reality of a mean kidnapping drama staged by an ordinary man ruined in his mind by the bitterness after the loss of his wife, a black and white drama of how Greta's efforts to save and regain her husband get drowned by too many people engaging in the business, and one even getting murdered for it, was enough for her, and she didn't make any more films, while at the same time she had made a career in films prominent enough by her beauty. The director here was Arthur Crabtree who directed many of the great British films of the 40s and also was an excellent cinematographer - this was also his last film. So this criminal drama is a kind of a curiosity, an almost documentary investigation of how a kidnapping drama must not be handled, as the more cooks who boil the soup, with worse the soup will get. It's not a bad film but only slightly above average, almost touching on B level.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed