"American Experience" D-Day Remembered (TV Episode 1994) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
10/10
A stunning technical achievement, and a refreshing break from the rubbish that composes modern cinema,
DemocraticEmpire0129 September 2005
D-Day Remembered * * * */ * * * *

"If you're going to die anyway, move in and die!"

D-Day Remembered is simply the story of the Allied Forces in the first few hours of June 6, 1944. For those unfamiliar with history, it was arguably the most important single event of the war. The invasion of Normandy, France pretty much laid out the groundwork for the rest of the war; the Axis Forces were demoralized, battered and had little reason to go on fighting. The war for Europe ended a little less than a year after D-Day.

In what the L.A. Times calls "a kind of film-making miracle," director Charles Guggenheim ingeniously combines archive film footage and pictures with the narration of historians and soldiers who took part in D-Day. History buffs like myself will be deeply immersed in the historical beauty of a film of this scope. This is not a "war film," like Saving Private Ryan, The Pianist or Patton. This is more like an art film, rare film archives that one interested in the subject would yearn to see. It's absolutely amazing how each scene is precisely shot, scene breaks and angles are perfect. A thrilling score accompanies.

This is as real and as close one will ever get to World War II. Roger Ebert did not like the film because he claimed it not to be feature-length and probably did not appreciate the hard-to-find film footage. In the hectic lives most people have these days, there's nothing like a 53-minute break to relish the efforts of 150,000 brave men who were willing to make the ultimate sacrifice for their country on film. After seeing more than six hundred films so far (not having commented on them yet), I was looking really forward to seeing rare film footage of a historical event I admire so much. I was not disappointed and I assure you won't be either.

The film is not easy to find, although a large library may have it in their historical films section. You can see, only nineteen people voted for it on IMDb! But that 9.0 you see is very well deserved. Watch this film with an open mind, don't expect Spielberg or Polanski, and you will be pleased.

Kudos to Charles Guggenheim. He did what no other documentary filmmaker may ever do: keep the viewer thoroughly engaged while keeping a bearable time limit. 10/10
8 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Overlord.
rmax30482324 July 2017
Aside from David McCullough's introduction, the program consists entirely of footage from England and Normandy.

There are brief sparse comments from participants -- British, Canadian, and American, not German -- about their personal impressions. One of the voices almost certainly is that of actor Charles Durning, though he's not listed in the credits. Durning was severely wounded on the beach and, recovered, went on to be captured and barely escaped the Malmedy Massacre in the Battle of the Bulge. Unlike so many veterans, Durning had no desire to return to Normandy on the 1994 anniversary.

The approach is personal, limited to individual experiences, and filled with sentiment. There is little mention of particular units or ships and nothing much about strategy. The technology goes unremarked.

The impression left with the viewer -- both by the images and by the commentary -- is that Murphy's Rule applied. If it could go wrong, it did. The result was chaos. Success was achieved through the leadership of individual brave soldiers. It's a dismally candid documentary that doesn't shun the images of dead Americans as well as dead Germans.

I'm not sure there is much here that isn't already familiar, at least in some sense, to most people who have any interest in World War II, but the presentation is not sensationalized or propagandistic. Well done.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed