I really liked this version of Verdi's majestic opera, with the lavish Egyptian settings. The only real things that bothered me was that some of the costumes looked as though they came from other opera productions. For instance, Amneris's dress looked like something out of Turandot, and Rhadames' looked rather Wagnerian, and also how badly the grand march was choreographed. The acting was variable with Dimitrova coming off best, but I was very impressed with the singing. Luciano Pavarotti makes a noble hero, more in the voice than in the acting, though he has been better in the 1988 version of La Boheme. I was also impressed with the beauty in voice and looks of Maria Chiara and she is a very competent actress, though she doesn't quite surpass Leontyne Price as the finest contemporary Aida. Juan Pons and Ghena Dimitrova do respectively as Amonasro and Amneris especially Dimtrova, but the real star was Nicolai Ghiaurov as Ramfis, with his rich noble voice and commanding stage presence. The whole production looks lovely, and the score is wonderful with Celeste Aida, The Grand March, The Nile Aria, and the act 4 finale the definite highlights. A good production, marred by the costumes and the choreography. For the best production, look no further than the 1989 Met production. 8/10 Bethany Cox.
4 Reviews
A little story of an Ethiopian slave and the fortunes of war
Bernie444410 May 2024
I have to confess I have not watched much of Verdi so I do not have enough knowledge to compare and contrast. I also was watching subtitles the first time through. Looks like I will have to find a different production and hope it is just not Giuseppe Verdi I find bland. I know this 1985 but it has a 60's feel.
This presentation seems a bit bland. But Stefania Toczyska made a splendid Amneris and kept you in your seat wanting more.
Do not let me discourage you from watching as everyone needs to know the story and especially find where they extracted the Act 2, Scene 2: ....Triumphal March from.
"Aida" an Arabic female name meaning "visitor"
This presentation seems a bit bland. But Stefania Toczyska made a splendid Amneris and kept you in your seat wanting more.
Do not let me discourage you from watching as everyone needs to know the story and especially find where they extracted the Act 2, Scene 2: ....Triumphal March from.
"Aida" an Arabic female name meaning "visitor"
Very good Aida, though with some imperfections
AngelofMusic199822 April 2024
Aida is one of my favorite Verdi operas and this 1985 La Scala production was good, though with some imperfections. Some costumes looked a bit unfitting for the Ancient Egypt setting of Aida,especially the costumes of Amneris and Radames. The Triumphal Scene (grand march) was badly choreographed. Luciano Pavarotti makes a really noble hero as Radames, more so in the voice than the acting. Ghena Dimitrova, a soprano, here sings the mezzo soprano role of Amneris. She was the best actor of the trio. Maria Chiara as Aida has a lovely voice and acts well. Overall, very good Aida, with the imperfections in the costumes and The Triumphal Scene 8/10.
Balance between music and pageant
hasko4 March 2004
This version of Verdi's Aida was performed on stage, and was never meant to be a movie, actually I don't think a full movie version of this opera was ever produced. But a stage production and a movie are different in many ways. Things that one can get away with in a stage production will show up clearly in a movie, for the camera will bring the spectator much closer to the set. There is nothing wrong with the music in this production, but the pageant is somewhat strange. This story was meant to be set in Ancient Egypt, but Radames looks more like a Viking warlord, and the priests look as if they have escaped from the temple in Jerusalem. I have a long standing problem with Italian costume designers, and this production has not improved matters, the Metropolitan version of Aida was much better in this respect.
One has to consider why one wants to watch opera, personally I like an even mix, and I am prepared to sacrifice some of the quality of the music in order to get a better pageant. Pavarotti is unequalled as a tenor, but as an actor, impersonating a tombstone is about as good as it gets. And as soon as Dimitrova appears on stage, one will immediately understand why Radames tries to flee into the arms of Aida. Finally, why those poor slaves had to drag those statues around all the time, and how g-string little boys fitted in, I haven't figured out yet. This version is probably ideal for flamboyant people. Personally I like a more historically accurate approach.
One has to consider why one wants to watch opera, personally I like an even mix, and I am prepared to sacrifice some of the quality of the music in order to get a better pageant. Pavarotti is unequalled as a tenor, but as an actor, impersonating a tombstone is about as good as it gets. And as soon as Dimitrova appears on stage, one will immediately understand why Radames tries to flee into the arms of Aida. Finally, why those poor slaves had to drag those statues around all the time, and how g-string little boys fitted in, I haven't figured out yet. This version is probably ideal for flamboyant people. Personally I like a more historically accurate approach.
See also
Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews
