"Hawaii Five-O" Right Grave - Wrong Body (TV Episode 1974) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
6/10
This is an enjoyable episode but the script needed to be tightened up...
planktonrules29 August 2011
Warning: Spoilers
It must be hard producing a one-hour show for TV. I've heard that the hours are grueling and each episode can be like a little movie--and you need to make 26 of them for each season (more or less). So, when little mistakes sneak into a show, I am not at all surprised. However, this one seemed to have more than its share. Fortunately, the basic story is good so you can still enjoy it.

The episode begins with a bunch of graves being excavated. You assume they're being relocated for some reason--but why isn't really important. What IS important is that buried amidst these graves is a body without a coffin--a body that has been there for about five years. The police soon learn the dead man's identity--he's a guy who was involved in a huge robbery where $250,000 was stolen. The police had assumed that he'd gotten away and was enjoying the sweet life. But, the forensics indicate that he was killed soon after the robbery. What happened?! And, what happened to the money? Soon, there are some killings at some liquor store holdups on the island. And, it turns out the gun used in these killings was the one that killed the guy at the beginning of the show. So, Five-O takes all the composite pictures they have of the assailant and canvas the island. One thing is troubling, though, and that it one of the reports--that of a cop from HPD--appears to be deliberately wrong--as if to lead the investigation in the wrong direction. Why? There's a lot more to the episode than this, but I don't want to ruin the suspense.

As I said above, there were a good number of mistakes in this episode. First, Five-O said that the gun that killed the guy at the beginning of the show (the body dumped in the grave) also killed a bank teller during the robbery. That simply is impossible--especially when you learn whose gun killed the man in the grave. Second, when the skeleton is unearthed, they didn't do a very good job of hiding the fact that it was a science classroom or medical school skeleton. Despite the dirt all over it, you can CLEARLY see where the top of the skull was removed to allow students to look inside the skeleton (a standard practice). Are we to believe that the guy was killed and then the assailant sawed off the top of the skull with a precision tool just for the heck of it before dumping the corpse?! Third, when the guy who killed the original corpse comes upon the guy who now has the gun, what are the odds?!?! Also, can $250,000 really be shoved into a standard-sized tool kit??! All of these are legitimate questions that the writer and director SHOULD have worked out before shooting the show.

Overall, enjoyable but filled with more holes than a block of Swiss cheese.
4 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Problems
VetteRanger22 March 2023
Hawaii Five-0 had some issues with scripts in season seven. This isn't the worst one, but it's not a story that makes much sense, as it relies not only on ridiculous coincidence, but also some unreconcilable logical fallacies.

The idea is that an unsolved bank robbery five years ago involved a gun which suddenly pops up in a series of liquor store holdups in the current day. Secondly, a policeman five years ago had a shootout with one of the bank robbers and wound up with the entire haul .... $250,000.

The bank robber's body is discovered as a coffin is being dug up. There's no explanation of why. The gun turns out to be the policeman's gun, which was reported lost three years ago.

I suppose the issue is matching the bullet which killed the bank robber to the bullets used in the liquor store robberies and finding that the policeman killed the bank robber ... but the script really doesn't make enough of the point. You'd better be thinking more deeply than normal to get that. LOL

Then the same policeman happens upon the aftermath of one of the robberies in progress using the gun he lost three years ago, so he moves heaven and earth to beat 5-0 to the crook.

All in all, if you skip this episode you're not missing much.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed