User Reviews

Review this title
8 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
The Last 90-Minute "Quincy" Provides an Enjoyable Mystery
Aldanoli10 September 2009
The last of the 90-minute episodes of "Quincy" is probably the best of those shows, though it also demonstrates that changing the format to the standard 1-hour show may not have been such a bad idea. "Quincy" was at its best when our eponymous hero had the least to work with, and this episode, with Quincy literally building a whole human being from a single thigh bone, shows him at his best.

The episode begins with the apparent villain slugging a security guard at a campus construction site and then (rather easily) pulling bones, a gun, and some clothing out of the dirt where earth-moving equipment has already been working. But he misses a few pieces, and the next day the construction foreman tells his workers to dispose of the remaining bones found there — fearing a work stoppage over what might be an Indian burial site.

In the meantime, Dr. Astin has assigned Dr. Quincy to teach a forensic pathology class at the same university, and one of his students (played by Linda Kelsey, soon to take on the role of Billie Newman in "Lou Grant") obtains this bone through means not shown on-screen. Even though she's only planning to be a psychiatrist, and doesn't recognize it as a human bone, she nevertheless brings it to Quincy's class — after which, one might say, complications ensue.

Other commentators have complained — sometimes justifiably — about the trimming of this and the other early episodes of "Quincy" from their original 90-minute length to an hour for syndication. But in this case it might have been a blessing, because this episode has a number of sequences that are nothing but padding. The "Crazy Credits" note on this page, for example, observes that a scene with Tina Andrews (as a black protester) was cut out. With due respect to Ms. Andrews, however, that scene is completely superfluous; it did nothing to advance the story, and the other protesters either make noise or fall silent on cue, coming across like . . . well, like something staged for a television program.

Otherwise, besides Kelsey, the episode features a young Stephen Macht; a brief scene with Kelsey's future "Lou Grant" co-star Jack Bannon; and a small part by a pre-"Love Boat"/pre-Congress Fred Grandy. It's a fine illustration of what made "Quincy" enjoyable to watch, as our hero picks up clues from obscure things like the amount of fluoride in the dead man's bone, an apparent bullet wound and knee injury visible on the bone, and the possibility that the dead man was an early casualty of the Vietnam War.

The last point leads to an interesting, ironic link to this show. It isn't true, as stated in this episode, that American troops didn't go to Vietnam until 1965 — the earliest names on the Vietnam memorial were "combat advisers" whose deaths date from 1959. And the first mention on an American television program of a combat casualty in South Vietnam likely came during an episode of "The Twilight Zone" first broadcast in September, 1963. The episode was entitled "In Praise of Pip," and the character who mentions Vietnam was played by a gifted, intense actor ... named Jack Klugman.
9 out of 9 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
"If you want to get into bed with Quincy it's up to up." The butchered 44 minute edit...
poolandrews27 September 2007
Warning: Spoilers
Quincy M.E.: ...The Thigh Bone's Connected to the Knee Bone... starts as LA coroner Quincy (Jack Klugman) gets ready to take a forensic pathology class at a local university, one of the students has brought in a thigh bone she found on a nearby building site for Quincy & the class to have a look at. Quincy's interest in immediately raised when he discovers not only is the bone human but show's signs of a nick which was probably caused by a bullet, attempts to find the rest of the bones at the building site fail & neither his boss Dr. Asten (John S. Ragin) or LA cop Lt. Monahan (Garry Walberg) are as convinced as Quincy the bones owner was murdered. Together with his enthusiastic students & his lab's equipment Quincy sets out to discover as much as he can about the bone, who it belonged to & if they were murdered...

Episode 3 from season 2 this Quincy story was directed by Alex March & I have to say that this is perhaps the absolute quintessential Quincy episode that showcases everything that was great about the show. Before I carry on I have to say that I saw the butchered 44 minute version rather than the original 75 minute one, I presume these longer episodes (which this was the last) were edited down to the standard Quincy length for maybe repeat runs to bring them in line with future shorter episodes that were made after the 75 minutes ones or to conform to a specific one hour time slot, certainly here in the UK Quincy has always been shown in a standard weekly one hour time slot. Anyway, while I have never seen the longer edit of this one the short one works perfectly well & is one of my very favourite Quincy episodes that contain many of my favourite Quincy traits, the humour & banter between character's, the way he uses his medical skills & knowledge to reconstruct an entire person from one single bone, the way he solves a murder because of it, the way he fights bureaucracy including his own boss & the police force, the way he sticks up for & defends his own opinions & findings when all around him are questioning them, his obligatory impassioned speeches, the character relationships are just great with real chemistry & there's a really neat murder mystery plot here as well that grips & holds one interest right through to a good solid ending. Since this has over half an hour cut out of it one would hope it moves along at a nice pace & it certainly does, I'm not sure if the extra footage really changes the episode or whether anything vitally important was cut but it seemed fine to me & all the major plot points seem to be there & it makes perfect sense.

The one thing that sticks out during this episode as a plot hole is that the killer managed to convince the victims father that his son volunteered for & was killed during fighting in the Vietnam war in 1957, I'm not being funny here but the first U.S. combat troops didn't arrive in Vietnam until 1965... This one also has some horrible opening credits which omit the 'gentlemen you are about to enter the most fascinating...' speech at the start & an episode of Quincy without that just seems odd to me, I'm not sure if the rest of season 2 also used these credits though. The acting is alright although it's Klugman again who is just brilliant in the role, I also have to mention Asten & the horribly dated hat he wears at the start as it looks ridiculous!

...The Thigh Bone's Connected to the Knee Bone... is brilliant Quincy, from the fascinating medical techniques he uses to uncover & solve a murder to everything that makes Quincy great as a series, it's all here although bear in mind I saw the 44 minute edit...
5 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Show is improving
xbatgirl-3002923 March 2022
Warning: Spoilers
This last Quincy movie before the series started is definitely an improvement over the previous 2. This makes sense, as most shows can take a little while to figure themselves out. The story moved along much faster and there was actually a little suspense. Quincy was occasionally in a good mood for a change, instead of non-stop yelling at people. Even his boss, Asten, was not as weaselly as in all the other movies and he stuck up for Quincy (a tiny bit).

I couldn't help but wonder when regulations went into place that if old bones are found on a construction site, work has to stop so a survey must be done. I guess it was after this was made and not before. I have to say, I kept expecting the one construction worker with a conscience to come forward and admit they threw some other bones away. That seemed natural after the earlier scene. It just kept feeling weird when it didn't happen. That whole scene seemed pretty pointless otherwise. The foreman went on to explain again why he didn't want to stop work in a later scene, so no exposition was needed. I agree with the other reviewer that the second scene with the protest also seemed unnecessary, except if some writer had an ax to grind and wanted to squeeze in a point about hating protesters or something. None of the students came off as sympathetic. Ok ok, there were plot holes in general. Plus the idea of building such an accurate drawing of the victim from one bone is pretty ridiculous. But none of that was enough to pull me out of the story.

I really enjoyed the "kids" in Quincy's class. I sort of wonder if there was an idea at one time to maybe keep them on for the series, since the casting seemed to gather better talent (for small parts) than we've seen in the other movies. Steven Macht especially did a good job but the woman from Lou Grant and the guy from Married With Children were very likable. Plus they all seemed to have actual background stories, like they were going to be around for a while. I did zone out a bit during some of their class debates though.

I'm a little sad we didn't get more of Quincy the professor and his class investigating murders. But this episode was still one of the more enjoyable ones in the series so far.
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Can I take Dr. Quincy's class?
rayoflite2428 July 2015
The Thigh Bone's Connected to the Knee Bone episode starts off with a security guard being knocked out an excavation site and the assailant collecting bones, a skull, a gun and clothing out of the dirt beneath. Later, a student in Quincy's forensic pathology university class brings in a human bone she also picked up at the site while walking to class. After examining the bone and finding damage consistent with a bullet wound, Quincy brings the class to the site where he halts construction and declares it a crime scene. He also does the same thing later at the city dump causing further disruption to sanitation services and making Lt. Monahan (Garry Walberg) and Dr. Asten (John S. Ragin) irate because they are not convinced that a crime took place. Quincy and his students are undeterred and begin the monumental task of trying to reconstruct the entire body of the victim from a single bone in an effort to help identify him and uncover the truth about his death.

This is overall a good cold case style episode of Quincy, but it is not without flaws as there are a couple of far-fetched elements and technical inaccuracies. First of all, in the opening scene the guard is knocked out at the exact spot where the skeleton and other items are buried and the attacker knows precisely where to dig. How would this be possible when the victim was buried there 20 years ago and the entire lot has been torn up and excavated since?? Another element of the story is that the victim's father was told in 1957 that he was killed while fighting in Vietnam which was should not have been a plausible explanation at the time as the troops were deployed much later.

These issues aside, this episode is quite enjoyable to watch at times and I especially enjoyed the scene where Monahan yells "A bone does not make a crime" and Quincy shuts him down saying "Let me give you a lesson in anatomy! The thigh bone's connected to the knee bone, the knee bone is connected to the shin bone..." as the students snicker in the background. Quincy is a great teacher in this one getting the students out of the classroom and into the field where he inspires young minds, and I can't help but feel like I would have had more of an interest in science had he been my teacher. Look out for a very young Fred Grandy of Love Boat fame as one of the students in Quincy's class.

Sadly, this is the final episode where Lynette Mettey appears as Quincy's girlfriend, Lee. In one particular scene, she calmly advises him to rethink the level by which he is involving the students because this is an official investigation and could prove dangerous. He doesn't heed her advice and one of the students is later attacked. This combination of patience, common sense and quiet resolve was exactly what the Quincy character needed in terms of balance in a female counterpart as opposed to who he ended up with later in the series which I won't get into. I wish Lee would have stuck around instead!
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
I felt I was denied vital need-to-know information...
AlsExGal31 January 2024
... and that is not surprising since this was one of the Quincy movies at 75 minutes made to fit in a 90 minute time-slot and pared down to 48 minutes to fit into a 60 minute time-slot for TV syndication. I feel like some key plot points might have been extracted in that 27 minutes that were discarded.

The episode has Quincy teaching a college course on forensic pathology to some medical students. One of the students finds a leg bone at a construction site and brings the bone to class. Quincy notices that the bone has a bullet wound and thus wonders where the rest of the body is and how the person died, assuming it was foul play. The class goes to the site, but cannot find the rest of the body. Thus Quincy takes that one bone and determines through forensic science a lot about the physical appearance of the human it once belonged to.

There are lots of conclusions drawn in this episode, especially when the investigation segues from what the person looked like to WHO the person actually was. Some of the clues leading to the conclusions made do not appear to be in the episode with the emphasis being more on the dramatic moments as far as what got retained in the syndication version. The DVD set of the series has the complete movies rather than the syndicated versions of these episodes in case you are that curious.

As an aside, at the construction site where the bone was found, Monohan and Dr. Astin show up to chide Quincy for getting in way of the construction project there. Monohan is in his customary gray suit, but Dr. Astin shows up dressed like the white Shaft! I realize that 70s clothes look like something that is worn on a dare, but Astin's outfit is loud even by those standards.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
One of my favorite episodes
wesperkins3 February 2024
I have seen some other reviews that do a very thorough job of giving synopsis of the episode, So I won't go into too much detail about the episode's plot. There are some plot holes if you watch the shortened version, that I am sure are addressed in the longer version. I remember a couple times wondering what was going on with a certain student of his, And why he was acting the way he did. But what I like about this episode is the interaction between the students and Quincy, And how once again he has to fight city hall to prove he is correct. Eventually you would think people would start believing him when he is always correct. What I really liked was that this was CSI before CSI was a thing. I always find it fascinating to watch '70s shows and looking in the background at what life was like back then as well. I know when I get into a Quincy binge, this is one of the episodes I always like to watch. Overall it's just one of my favorites.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
I am totally confused about how long this episode is supposed to be...
planktonrules5 March 2013
The show begins with a guard being slugged at the site of a construction dig. Apparently, some unknown person wanted access to the place so they could remove some bones from a long-dead corpse. Considering this has occurred at a university, Quincy enlists the help of some med students there to help identify the body. That's because although MOST of the bones were stolen by this unknown person, a femur was left behind accidentally. What use is an old femur and why would someone nearly kill a guard to get the bones anyway?

I noticed that IMDb says that this episode of "Quincy" ("The Thigh Bone's Connected to the Knee Bone") is the last of the 90-minute time slot shows and that it clocks in at 75 minutes. However, I have been watching "Quincy" episodes on Netflix and this one was only about 48 minutes (the standard time for all the shows after this episode). Which is correct? And, is the Netflix version a severely edited version? I assume the latter is the case, as the show seemed to jump around a bit too much--with some very abrupt transitions. My guess is that the show was trimmed down when the show was syndicated in the 1980s in order to make this one fit the standard time slot. My question then is where can I find the full-length version? The one on Netflix and the DVD is the shortened version. And, because the show is apparently heavily trimmed, this should be kept in mind when reading my review.

Because of what I said above, it's not surprising that I didn't particularly love this episode. While I really enjoy the show, this one didn't seem all that well constructed and seemed to take many logical leaps. Again, you can't necessarily blame the show--the original episode probably was a lot more coherent. All in all, passable but far from the show's best. And, after being a regular on all the previous episodes, this one marked the final appearance of Lynette Mettey as Quincy's VERY long-suffering girlfriend. She, like several others, would disappear after a while--and you assume this is due to Quincy's crazy and often dangerous life.
6 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
...The Thigh Bone's Connected to the Knee Bone...
Prismark107 August 2019
This episode highlights Quincy's forensic skills as he manages to build a portrait of person from just a femur that was found.

The bone was found in a dig on the university campus and bought to a university class that Quincy is about to give a lecture to. However Quincy notes that there is a bullet nick and wants to explore more. It means shutting down the excavation which annoys the contractors. Also a security guard was knocked out during the dig site the night before.

Lt Monahan is irate at Quincy's actions who has now roped in the students to join him in his investigations. Dr Astin is once again put under immense pressure and has to reluctantly back Monahan, who is rapidly becoming California's worst homicide cop as he completely ignores the attack on the security guard. However one person cautions Quincy that his rash actions could place the students in danger and one of them nearly dies as one interested spectator watches all the goings on closely.

I watched the cut down version of this episode so it might not all make narrative sense. Also this is an episode where the they get a creepy looking guy to be the villain of the week. I was surprised why this person was able to walk around the university campus without arousing any suspicion. Then again Quincy's students were all on the mature side. Stephen Macht who is one the medical students looked about 40.

The biggest fault given that this was made in 1977 was how they could get the date of the Vietnam war wrong. The victim identified was supposedly to have died in the Vietnam war 20 years earlier. Very shoddy writing but it is still an enjoyable but far fetched episode.
1 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed