"South Park" A Very Crappy Christmas (TV Episode 2000) Poster

(TV Series)

(2000)

User Reviews

Review this title
5 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
7/10
Saving the Spirit of Christmas!
ExplorerDS678922 December 2012
Warning: Spoilers
It seems the Christmas spirit is vacant in South Park this year. Nobody is shopping or celebrating as they once did. What's more, when Kyle leaves milk and cookies on the toilet for Mr. Hankey, he doesn't come. So he wakes Stan, Cartman and Kenny out of a sound sleep and drags them into the sewers to find him. Turns out Hankey has settled down and started a family, complete with drunk lush wife Autumn, and three kids, though only one of them serve any purpose in the story. The Hankey kids go with the boys to try and spread Christmas cheer, but no luck. So the boys go home and watch A Charlie Brown Christmas, or a very twisted facsimile. They find this classic cartoon to be lame, but then Kyle hits upon the brilliant idea of making their own animated Christmas special. They take their idea to the mayor and ask for a $300 budget...construction paper must be pretty expensive now adays. She thinks the idea is stupid, but is desperate enough to try it, and so the boys commission Butters to create little paper cut-outs of them, plus Jesus and Santa, and even a little version of Butters for good measure. And so, the boys commence on their stop-motion cartoon, finding it simple and enjoyable, but tedious as all hell. After berating Cartman for sneezing on their scene, he walks. At this point, it seems hopeless, but Kyle sings about how even a miracle needs a hand, so they ship their materials off to Korea to finish, and get the final film soon after. Oh, and Kenny dies during the song, so they decide to kill off his character in the special.

Hankey's son Cornwallis is having an existential crisis, so his father sings about how crap isn't a part of life, but that it IS life. Circle of life...I advise you not to eat while watching this part. Then after that, the premiere of the boys' animated Christmas card, "The Spirit of Christmas." They set it up in the old drive-in, despite the fact nobody was driving a car. While the animation was crappy and the voice acting amateur, the special seemed decent enough, but sadly, the projector catches fire, ending the show early. It seemed that Christmas was doomed. But then, Cornwallis reminds Mr. Hankey of the lesson he taught him, and so they somehow repair the projector and the film. The Spirit of Christmas was one weird, but intriguing special: Jesus and Santa fight, then the boys learn the true meaning of the holiday: presents. The folks of South Park take the meaning to heart and begin shopping. So all was well again.

Have to say, this one is my least favorite of the South Park Christmas specials. Maybe it has to do with Mr. Hankey's uninteresting family. Seriously, his wife is horrible to him and only one of his kids serves any purpose, which is ironic because he feels he has no purpose. Or maybe we're familiar with the history of The Spirit of Christmas, so that was nothing new to us. It does give a good insight into how something like that was made. Stop-motion animation is simple and cheap, but it is extremely tedious, especially if you're working solo, not like Rankin/Bass who had a whole team of animators in Japan making their specials. Anyway, it's still an enjoyable episode if you look past Hankey's family. Also, I have seen The Spirit of Christmas in full...both of them. Poorly animated, but the story is decent enough and it's got it where it counts, which is really all that matters.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Gives us glimpses of the "Spirit Of Christmas 1995" short film
gangstahippie25 December 2008
Before South Park, Trey Parker and Matt Stone made two animated Christmas short films featuring early versions of the South Park characters.You can find them both on youtube, but this episode gives us some glimpses of the 1995 Spirit of Christmas.The boys see that nobody is buying them presents because they do not want to celebrate with material things.So the mayor asks them to create a Christmas short which should send them into a shopping frenzy.The boys try to make one.They make the spirit of Christmas short and their experiences with it mirror the ones Trey and Matt had when they made it.Meanwhile, Mr Hankey has a family which is why he has been busy this year.This is a funny and good Christmas episode!
6 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Finally a good Mr. Hankey episode
apotheosis-of-war19 July 2022
Been a few days since I began to rewatch the series and not being a big fan of the previous christmas specials I had low expectations, but it turns out it was very funny and a pretty cool homage to the original short film.
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
most underrated South Park episode of all time?
sneakymeeky-5701621 November 2023
Warning: Spoilers
This show has had a lot of classic episodes over the years. But, like a diamond in the rough - or a peanut in your turd - this one somehow shines in such a perfect way.

I know I must have watched A Very Crappy Christmas at some point before, because Hankey the Christmas Poo's wife and kids are such memorable characters! ..but if that were so, then how could I have forgotten The Circle of Poo musical number halfway through, and the moment Cornwallis starts being it out? Nor had I any recollection of the episode's main arc, and how it opened the door for deliciously self-referential antics throughout. If it's your first time watching South Park in your life, the meta humor still works in how it pokes fun at itself, even some shedding light on the show's animation in the process. Genuinely clever routines, with the back drop of 4th graders saying "fatass"... and it's *just* inoffensive enough that I might make my family watch it with me next time we're all gathered for everyone's favorite holiday 💩🎄

Such a perfect Christmas Special! It has everything that makes early South Park so timelessly hilarious, up to and including Ike's little toddler voice. Either I'm just stoned out of my mind, or this episode has a real case for being one of the most underrated episodes in the show's history. 10/10.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Good episode!
Dr_Death66618 May 2009
This is an episode of South Park from season 4. It's about the 4 boys wanting to wish Mr Hankey The Christmas Poo a Merry Christmas, so they make an animated movie, which is basically "The Spirit Of Christmas", an old animated short Trey Parker and Matt Stone made back in 1995, which started South Park, which can be seen on the South park Hits DVD. Anyway, I liked this episode a lot. It's not one of the top 10 best, but it still is pretty good. Definitely worth watching online or on the season 4 DVD set (which I own, actually I own every episode of South Park)

9/10 or: A-
4 out of 11 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed