Tuya's Marriage (2006) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
31 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Great movie, but why not in Mongolian?
matsuo-110 February 2007
I just finished watching Tuya's marriage at the Berlin Film Festival and would rate it 8/10. The movie deals with a herder woman in Inner Mongolia who decides to divorce because her husband is sick and unable to care for her and the family. Since she still loves him, any prospective new husband must promise to care for her and the kids as well as for her old husband.

The plot may sound a bit constructed, but it actually works remarkably well. The pictures are great, and after D. Byambasuren's rather static movies this is finally a drama set in the steppes. The most important thing is probably that the movie takes its subjects seriously. Maybe a bit too seriously at times, but not that seriously that it disturbs the movie.

So, why not giving it 10/10? I missed the Mongolian language. Of course language isn't everything (see Mongolian Pingpong or Apocalypto), but when even the drinking habits are dealt with in greatest detail, why didn't they bother to find a cast that can speak Mongolian? I asked the director about why they used Chinese (that's what you go on film festivals for), but his answer was not really convincing. I suppose some opportunistic reason, like the main actress can't speak Mongolian. Anyway, this only means that you can as well enjoy this movie in a dubbed version.

In short: Definitely recommended.
14 out of 18 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Exotic
paulmartin-226 July 2007
This is an exotic film that recalls other indigenous Mongolian tales by Byambasuren Davaa such as The Story of the Weeping Camel (2003) or The Cave of the Yellow Dog (2005). It also has much in common with the Tibetan film Himalaya (1999) and rural Iranian cinema. The story, like that in each of these other films, is very simple - a woman's husband is incapacitated and she seeks a new man who will support the old.

The cinematography is beautiful with the harshness of the inner Mongolian landscape captured aesthetically. Dialogue is sparse, and the film is very observational, documenting a way of life that is gradually receding into the past. The herding and riding of animals, the digging of wells, the visits from potential suitors and other aspects of rural life are nicely captured, and contrast against the oncoming tide of modernity.

Thematically, the film has more in common with Breaking the Waves (1996), my favourite Lars von Trier film. There is both humour and heartbreak as the story unfolds. I didn't find the film quite as effective as Weeping Camel but a nice bit of cultural diversity that's worth seeing.
13 out of 17 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
the main protagonist is a woman
venkat19269 May 2009
One of he most interesting films from chines mainland. There are no stunt fights, no killings. This is a human story with human complexities and how a strong woman tries to solve her problem. He enduring love and affections for her disabled husband and her children constitute the main theme. In the background there is another actor, THE LANDSCAPE. Even though the steppe land with brushes and those mountains are harsh to the inhabitants, on screen it looks breathtaking. The film shows how women were doing back-breaking chores(literally in this case) for ages for which man has to be thankful and gracious to her. An absorbing film to watch.
5 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
Almost a documentary
harry_tk_yung9 April 2007
This movie is more meaningful when viewed as a semi-documentary. Through the micro angle of a slightly dramatized story of Tuya, we are introduced to the macro reality of the harsh livelihood of the backward areas of Mongolia and, although not specifically addressed, of many parts of China.

Tuya's predicaments are by no means unique, or even unusual, for there are many areas in the mainland where natural resources that we in modern cities take for granted are luxuries. With her husband paralyzed as a result of attempts to drill wells for water, Tuya, relatively young, reasonably good looking and unquestionably able-bodied, takes up the burden of rearing a herd if lambs and caring for her husband and two children. The son, just about turning teen, is a help but the daughter is small. When the burden comes close to being unbearable, the couple resorts to what a lot of people in similarly locations under similar situations do. The have a divorce, and the wife looks for an opportunity for re-marrying, to a man capable of taking care of the children. In Tuya's case, there is another condition: the suitor must undertake to take in the paralyzed ex-husband.

The story, as the title suggests, revolves around the events leading to Tuya's marriage, or re-marriage. The events unfold in as natural a manner as can be presented in a movie. There are moments of both farce and pathos, but none is contrived. You can believe that this is exactly the way things would happen. YU Nan who plays Tuya is a marvelous actress. All the other key characters are real local people, using their real names in the movie, but I am not sure whether they are indeed acting out their own story.

"Tuya' marriage" won the Golden Berlin Bear earlier this year, a last-minute entry in the competition and a surprise winner.
28 out of 30 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Some specific points
enaskitis-122 January 2008
Warning: Spoilers
I liked this movie. The story is interesting, woman-centered, Yu Nan's acting is excellent, the social commentary is interesting, the non urban setting is a refreshing change from the usual stuff, without making a travel guide of the film at all. It also combines drama and humor in a nice way. It doesn't become melodramatic, thank God. The end of the story is poised between happy and sad, which is how life is in the majority of the cases. Now, some specific negative points:

I would prefer the film to be in the Mongolian language, too.

The family looks very poor, they only have a small herd of sheep, yet they own a camel, a horse and a donkey. I'm not an expert on this, but it looks as too much to me, compared with the number of the income-generating sheep.

The scene where Shenge catches up with the Mercedes on the highway by riding on a horse is absurd. What's more, Shenge didn't even know the whereabouts of Tuya and her prospective husband at that moment.

When Tuya, Shenge, Maoter and the kids return home from the above failed matching, Tuya starts again herding her sheep and all. But, since they had previously left their home supposedly forever, they should have sold everything: sheep, camel, house, etc. So that's absurd too.

At the final wedding scene, it's impossible that Maoter (the ex-husband) would disrupt the proper procedure of the ceremony by starting to sing his own tune. Why? Well, because, first, he himself had prodded Tuya since the beginning to find a new husband; second, he later actively approved of this specific husband, namely Shenge; third, earlier in the film this Shenge had practically saved his life after his suicide attempt in the asylum, and then he had even brought his wife back. And Maoter is a very good, quiet, logical person. So his reaction is illogical and unbelievable, even allowing for the effect of the additional cup of alcohol : too much is at stake. The screenwriters should have found here another idea to convey their message that even after this happy ending life will not be cloudless within the new household. Tuya's boy fighting with a neighbor boy because the latter scolded him for having "two fathers" is, on the contrary, a much more successful idea that serves the same purpose.
5 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Definitely worth a Berlin Golden Bear
champsonliu13 May 2007
Tuya' marriage is among one of the most successful attempts by China's sixth-generation directors to make a good film. Other equally successful ones included the Beijing Bicycle, the Little Red Flowers, etc, which were all made by film directors not quite familiar to Western viewers --- at least not as known as big names like Zhang Yimou.

The film is so real to life and depicts the life on the vast lands of Inner Mongolia so well, that it reminds me of my piecemeal impressions gathered during my trip to Inner Mongolia six years ago --- people were impoverished but so kind, materially backward but spiritually advanced, and the traditional way of life is preserved well.

Yu Nan's performance is really amazing. The plot is so moving and touching that at some points I felt so much involved as to worry about Sengge's death through drilling.

This is a new kind of experience even for Han Chinese to learn about the Mongolian life, and I hope it can be the same kind of revealing experience for audience in the West to understand the ethnic diversity in China --- Mongolians live harmoniously with Han Chinese in the same country called "China", just as it is the case with the other 55 minorities, including Tibetans.

In a nutshell --- Tuya's Marriage indeed deserves the Golden Bear at Berlinale, be it in essence or in name.
14 out of 18 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
The Depiction of Semi-Modern Chinese Society
joannachen7617 December 2007
Warning: Spoilers
Though some may consider Tuya's Marriage as an art film, it is more like a depiction of the society in inner-Mongolia, China. Based on the amount of Chinese literary and film works, the story itself of a woman marrying another man to support her Ex is not uncommon in the more aboriginal areas in China. But the way this picture filmed Tuya's story: Tuya's camel compared to Sen'ge's motorcycle and truck, and the rich suitor's Benz; and the trip from the desert to the hotel closer to the city, viewers can see what China is really like now.

I believe that besides telling Tuya's story (which is based on an actual story), the director also wants to show viewers how the semi-modern Chinese society works, and how it has an impact on the lives of people living in different parts of China. Tradition and landscape really isn't the point in this movie, there are many details in here regarding to the characters' daily lives that viewers can compare to themselves, which I believe would be interesting to do. Take myself for example, I live right across the strait from mainland China and I could never imagine myself leading a life in inner-Mongolia like Tuya.
3 out of 4 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Tuya's Marriage: A rare window into rural China
slt208 September 2010
Warning: Spoilers
An unexpected gem in the middle of the desert, this quiet drama proves itself fully deserving of its Golden Bear at the 2007 Berlin annual film festival.

Sixth generation, Mainland Chinese film director Wang Quanan once again bands with actor, and ex-partner of ten years, Nan Yu, to turn his attention to the rural side of life in China- a focal point of his 2004 film The Story of Ermei, which told the story of a young Shaanxi peasant girl. This time 'Tuya's Marriage' takes us into the depths of the vast and arid grasslands of Inner Mongolia. Though its plot is fairly straight forward, and dialogue simple, this quiet and understated film stands strong in its realistic portrayal of rural life, natural acting style, and breath taking landscape.

Her husband crippled after digging a well, strong and persevering Tuya must labour, herding sheep and lugging water from a faraway waterhole, to keep her husband and two young children alive. But the young, and still beautiful Tuya can no longer be the sole carrier of her family's burden- she is suffering from lumbar fatigue caused by over exhaustion, and faces possible lower body paralysis. Her husband agrees that she must find a new suitor to marry. This doesn't prove to be so easy though, as Tuya, still faithful to her old husband, is resolute that whoever wishes to marry her must also be prepared to care for him too.

Mainland Chinese born actor Nan Yu is well fitted in her role as the independent Tuya. The fact that Nan Yu spent several months living in rural Mongolia prior to filming has given her a great understanding and confidence in the role and comes off as a genuine Inner Mongolian grasslands shepherdess. Tuya's costume potentially could have swallowed many actors whole- she is swathed in numerous, bulky layers of clothing and wrapped tightly in a head scarf- but Nan Yu's expressive face works to bring Tuya to life.

Tuya is an independent, incredibly strong woman. She is a shepard to the men around her- her disabled husband Baotoer, her likable but foolish friend Shenge who always falls on bad luck, and even her younger son. She has an incredibly strong loyalty towards her husband "The only way I'd leave him is if I became worse than him" and for his sake turns down many suitors who could have been a way out of poverty for her. But there are a few times when we get to see another side of Tuya's tough exterior. My favourite scene is when we see her, taken away from the farm and work, sitting together with her friend Shenge in his brand new truck. Orange light shines on them from the setting sun, and as they look forward into the distance Shenge speaks of the uncertainties of the future. For a moment we see a fragile young woman, no different from ourselves, who is lost in a big, and changing world.

If Nan Yu is the star of the movie, then the landscape would have to be her co-star. Absolutely stunning with it's never ending, barren desert and clear blue skies, the long shots show the vastness of the land and isolation of the characters. The women in the film wear brightly coloured head scarves- pink, red, purple, green- as a way of expressing them selves, and these headscarves are a striking contrast against the often dust coloured backdrop.

The use of music in this film is also truly effective. Traditional string instruments are often used, along with woman singing. The music is only used at the saddest times in the film, and is combined with long, enduring shots of the wild and desolate landscape. This creates a haunting feeling of loneliness and forlornness. Both landscape and music become symbolic of Tuya's situation- she is stranded with no solution in sight.

Tuya's Marriage generally fits into the drama genre. The film deals with realistic and totally believable characters, and explores how social issues such as poverty and alcoholism bring these characters into conflict with themselves, and the others around them. Poverty makes rural farm life in China tough, and relatively simple tasks such as watering the sheep become difficult because lack of adequate equipment- Tuya must travel 30miles a day just to fetch sufficient water. The question of day to day survival forces characters to make decisions that go against every part of their being-it becomes a cruelly ironic when the only way for Tuya to care for her disabled husband, Baotoer, who she loves, is to divorce him. Several of the characters look to alcohol to numb the pain. An older chain-smoking woman, worn out by life's trials, says "I'm raising six by myself with no man; if I didn't drink I don't know what I'd do."

In a sense Tuya's Marriage also becomes a documentary of Mongolian culture and traditional ceremonies, often putting a lot of focus on the landscape, the traditional ceremonies and dress, the music, and traditional foods such as head-to-tail lamb and milk tea. This makes the film a fascinating experience, but my only possible complaint is that this overtakes the films over focus on showing intimate interactions between the characters.

Beautiful and affecting, and often scattered with moments of humour and tenderness, Tuya's Wedding gives us a window into a seldom travelled world through the struggles of one young woman.
3 out of 3 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Tuya's condition for her marriage: he had to take care of her ex.
michaelyik9 April 2007
Warning: Spoilers
Just when the audience decided to sit back and relax to enjoy a plain, slow moving film shot in the Mogolian steppe, they found themselves grabbed by the unexpected twists and turns as the story unfolded.

Tuya was in great trouble. She hurt her back trying to save her neighbor. She had to look for a man to carry on with the work in the farm as her husband, Barter, was crippled. Suitors, including a high school secret admirer, flocked at her doorstep and she was not keen on any of them.

Tuya was about to resign to fate, when she found true love and solutions to her problems. The first scene was an exact duplicate of the last. Tuya shut herself up to weep, but then her new husband called her. She had to get out to face new challenges in her new life.

The exotic Mongolian music, both the singing and the instrumentals, and the shots of the grand steppe, distant mountains and the over hanging full moon added distinct flavor to the movie.

The plot somehow reminded me of Hardy's "Far From the Madding Crowd". The one was the one nearest to you and the one you had written off completely in the first place.
4 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
A moving drama about one woman trying to hold it all together
N.L.3 November 2007
Warning: Spoilers
Unlike the two faux documentaries which people now associate with Mongolian films, TUYA'S MARRIAGE is a well-acted, intricate and layered story about a strong young woman trying to hold her life together. Very like Gong Li in THE STORY OF QIU JU, Yu Nan plays Tuya, a stubborn and beautiful woman faced with an impossible predicament who must find her way through an onslaught of well-meaning (mostly) but ineffectual men to keep her family together. Tuya's affection for and loyalties to her disabled husband Bater are put to the test when she is forced to find a new husband in order to survive. All along the "obvious" choice, Shenge, her foolish but adorable neighbor, keeps trying to be the hero but falling on his face. Tuya must keep saving the men in her life from near disaster: Bater, Shenge (twice), and even her young son. The film becomes the romance/triangle of one woman and two men - much like JULES AND JIM or even FAREWELL MY CONCUBINE (co-written by Wei Lu, who also co-wrote TUYA'S MARRIAGE). At the end of the film, her marriage includes both men, but immediately we see that she must continue saving them from themselves - and keeping everything and everybody together.
9 out of 13 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Tuya's Marriage
lilopez9 March 2017
Warning: Spoilers
I would not say that I particularly liked or disliked Tuya's Marriage. This movie is listed as a romantic comedy, though there was romance, the movie was not that funny. There were only two moments where I might have laughed. On the other hand, the movie does hold my attention so much that I would watch it again. I think watching it again would give me a better understanding of what I have sees and possibly catch more "funny" moments.Something I found interesting is how Tuya is able to arrange her own marriage. Usually when you think of an arranged marriage, it is the parents not the persons getting married who sets up the marriage. Not only does she have control of who she marries but she also discusses terms and agreements within the marriage. The ending is also interesting because it is unclear and keeps you guessing. That may be the reason why I or anyone else would want to watch Tuya's Marriage again, to try and find the answers to some unresolved questions.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Another Open Window Into A Secret Culture
Seamus282913 July 2008
Any film that offers an open window into viewing other culture is always greeted with open arms (at least for me,anyway). 'Tuya's Marriage' is a tale that is set in Inner Mongolia about a thirty something woman named Tuya who is trying to get by,day for day with an older,disabled husband & young children. An opportunity arises for Tuya to make life a little better by getting re-married to a younger man,who (hopefully)would support her meager family. Trouble is,her choices are one disaster after another (including a wealthy suitor who fancied her in middle school). This film, although lushly photographed, seems to be stuck between wanting to be a black comedy, or an exercise in Asian existentialism. Still, the (mostly)non professional cast seems to play their roles well. This film is still worth checking out,none the less.
5 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Movie review reaction
japrice-268761 November 2017
Warning: Spoilers
The film Tuya's Marriage is not a happy one. The movie begins and ends with the same scene of her eventual wedding day, with her youngest son fighting with another boy who sneers at him for having two fathers. Tuya's marriage portrays a world that, apart from its hardship, is thoroughly recognizable. Its characters are motivated by the same needs for companionship and material well-being. And the same wants of greed, lust, jealousy and despair — that drive most people. Tuya, after breaking up the fight, retreats from the celebration to reflect. Tuya (protagonist) is physically disabled and married to and in love with a disabled peasant Ba'toer. Tuya (Yu Nan) is financially forced to divorce him and find a new husband to support herself, her 'ex' husband and their two children. She is called upon by suitors from near and far when word spreads of her decision to remarry. The film observes the fascinating rites of courtship and the unsentimental deal making by Tuya, who knows what she wants and what she has to do to get it. After a series of men refuse to look after Ba'toer, Tuya finds herself torn between a Baolier, a divorced childhood schoolmate of Tuya who is newly wealthy, having struck oil or a friend who promises to marry her once he finds and divorces his wife. Baolier's money and lust may represents the forces of technological change that is consuming the region. In Baolier's marriage proposal he agrees to take care of Bater by putting him in a nursing home, and Tuya agrees. However, it's not a good enough deal for Bater. Soon after arriving at his new him, he starts, feeling abandoned then pitifully gets drunk and slashes his wrists. The ending, like I said is not a happy one. Nonetheless, I'd recommend it to another friend or teacher.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Landscapes, clothes, traditions. Exotic and beautiful, but is it enough to make a good movie ?
moimoichan625 September 2007
The new generation of Chinese cineasts (the sixth, have I been told) tries to develop more personal projects than the previous one, by making movies that carry a individual story more than a collective one. Wang Quanan, with "Tuya", represents this new generation of Chinese directors, and tells in this movie a personal and individual story (his mother comes from the Mongolian area the film depicts) without trying to link it to the Chinese history, but he also creates a bridge with the previous one (his character of a strong woman reminds the portrayals that Gong Li has done with Zhang Yimou). But, unfortunately, the movie doesn't have the same originality of, for instance, his friend Jia Zhan-Ke's, nor doesn't manage to carry the same strength than Zhang Yimou's.

The story is like the movie, simple and a little bit plain : in a lost farm in Inner Mongolia (but still in China) Tuya has to find a new husband since her present one is unable to work. But she asks one condition to accept the new pretendant : he has to supplies for her ex-husband needs. But the movie seems to film the quest of Tuya like a pretext to show the beautiful landscapes of the area, the traditions that seem to survive here (as the marriage scene nicely shows it), an also typical Mongolian clothes, rituals and music. It's sure pretty and interesting, but more like a travel guide documentary than like a modern Chinese cinema piece of art.

Beside one or two good cinematographic interesting ideas (especially located at the very beginning and at the end of the movie ; and a good scene that show a woman crying at her wedding), there's nothing really passionating nor new there. Of course, cinema can sometimes be considered like a traveling substitute, but it also needs to be something more if the spectator really wants to enjoy the traveling.
3 out of 27 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
A quietly powerful story of female reverence
movedout6 April 2008
Wang Quanan's fascinating film "Tuya's Marriage" is a quietly powerful story of female reverence, shot on location against the arresting landscapes of deepest Mongolia, with its immensely graceful protagonist being the prepossessing shepherdess Tuya (Nan Yu), caught between a marital loophole and the tightening grip of subsistence when she's forced to look for a new husband willing to take care of her young children and an invalid ex-husband. Austere and gorgeous, Wang's observations on the encroaching capitalism in a rural land so entrenched in tradition and its collective, scuttles from background to foreground when Tuya explores her options and their economic viability. Wisely eschewing a formal romanticism of the arena, Wang takes us deeper into the all-encompassing humanism of the film, when he chooses a cogitative docu-drama approach to the film, a striking reminder that a film's aesthetics are part of its ethos and message. Triumphing at the 2007 Berlinale with the festival's top prize, Wang delivers a film so complex and rich that it finds its tracts in the human capacity for compassion and sorrow.
6 out of 7 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Tuya's Marriage
magonzalez-1576210 March 2017
Warning: Spoilers
Tuya's Marriage was an interesting movie to say the least. It was the first Mongolian film that I had ever seen, and it was also one of the most interesting to say the least. I felt like there was an interesting story behind the movie, but I felt as if the actors and director didn't really as much passion for this. Then again, this is coming from an American perspective rather than someone who is actually Mongolian, so I don't truly know how much they put in to this film. I did enjoy all of the camera angels in the film, as well as the location and props. They did a wonderful job recreating a Mongolian home. I also liked how well they all rode their horses during the film. It was clear that some time and thought was put in to making the actors ride as if they were Mongolian.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Great touching story
Moviespot4 March 2010
Tuya's marriage is a truly remarkable film showing the family changes and humanity of a Mongolian herds-family, The main actress plays the role of an incredible strong woman named Tuya. The liberal way of thinking of these Mongolian people can be a lesson to folks here in the west. Tuya's disabled husband even encourages her to separate from him because it's best for the family.Tuya however only wants to remarry if her ex husband will be accepted as a family member by her new husband. we follow Tuya on her way towards a new life with several would be-new husbands.a film full of love and caring of a people who live in two worlds , ancient way's of living and modernity. fascinating film and story.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Eye opening film
olrovin9 March 2017
Warning: Spoilers
Before viewing this film, I was very unfamiliar with Mongolian culture. I had always imagined the Mongolian people as a nomadic group who only lived in tents and constantly from place to place in large groups. It had never occurred to me that there were many Mongolians who did live in a stable place in homes. This movie definitely opened my eyes to that. It also made me think about the various issues that people face in different regions of the world. Tuya's issue was that her husband was crippled and she was at risk of becoming crippled so she needed to marry another man in order to support her family; however, this proved to be very emotional for Tuya and her husband, Bater. It was a slower paced movie but the visuals were very beautiful and intriguing. The director did a good job of portraying the landscape of Mongolia and setting up the scene so the viewer got a sense of the typical way of life in Mongolia. Overall I would give this film 3.5 out of 5 stars.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Marriage
fezhang-568304 November 2017
This movie makes me think about myself: compare the living conditions between Mongolia and us, I definitely think I am lucky, and thanks to my family. In Mongolia, the child needs to do a lot of work that I did not even try before, and they are lacking water resource. Also, their transportation is poor. Tuya's Marriage also shows their attitude of living, they do not give up, they still want to stay at their home instead of going to the city. Tuya is a strong woman, his husband is paralytic, so she needs to take care of her family by herself; she goes thousands of miles to get water and depasture sheeps every day, even she has physical problems. She divorced her husband in order to give a better condition to her family, she says everyone wants to marry me needs also need to support her ex-husband. The favorite scene in this movie is her child had been trapped in a wolf attack, she comes and says" do not worry, if these wolves attack you, I will eat them and leave these sheep here, I am gonna take you home". On this movie, I see a great mom, wife and a hot heart person.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Tuya's Marriage
hazimmer10 March 2017
Warning: Spoilers
Tuya's Marriage was, compared to most of the Asian films I've seen, kind of a letdown. I enjoyed it, but although the movie had a good premise, it didn't have high enough stakes or interesting moments to really catch my attention. The plot followed the title character, a shepherd named Tuya, who is married to her husband Batoer. Batoer, who is disabled, is unable to work as a shepherd, and when an injury also leaves Tuya unable to work, she is forced to divorce Batoer and remarry someone who can provide for him. After numerous men refuse to look after him, Tuya is torn between Baolier, a wealthy, recently-divorced man who works for an oil company, and Shenge, her neighbor whose wife has recently left him. Baolier proves to not be as good of a man as he seems, as Batoer tries to commit suicide and Baolier doesn't tell Tuya about it. Shenge also seems to not be who he seems at first, but turns out to have been digging the well as a source of income for Tuya, even if it meant hurting himself in the process. However, the relationship between Shenge and Tuya, instead of easily coming together, was made difficult by Tuya rejecting him, then accepting his advances, then rejecting him again. I feel like it would've had a bit more closure if the audience knew who she decided to marry, but it was never made clear. I'd only give this movie 3 out of 5 stars—it was okay, but it wasn't amazing by any means.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Beautiful and authentic feeling movie
Damadjunglist6 October 2012
Warning: Spoilers
Just a beautiful and authentic movie with beautiful scenery of Mongolia, China and gives a good idea of daily life of a different kind in this world. I especially liked the tranquil way it has been shot almost like a documentary style way of filming. Also the actress who plays Tuya in this movie has such a beautiful face that it's even noticeable tightly wrapped in her traditional headscarf. I can't say absolutely nothing negative about this movie. There should be much more movies like this coming out that not only have the ability to entertain you but even make people think about what we think life is really about.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Tuya and her Troubles
jageldbart7 November 2017
In my opinion, I do not believe that Tuya's Marriage is close to the movie I would recommend to everyone. The reason being is that it is slow paced, and does not truly go with any genre that I have dealt with in movies. But, this is why I am so intrigued by it, even though it is slow, it touched on important topics in world geography and people's lives and how they are affected when fate is unkind. I believe that this movie, even though it is not one I would recommend to everyone, is something that truly shows hardships and problems that happen in Inner Mongolia (which is situated in China). This movie does not really fall into a specific genre outside of extreme drama, but it is hard to realize this unless you take time after watching it to ponder the plot and the points made inside it. I think this is a movie more for someone looking to widen their eyes to problems in the world, and that want to understand how it can be in a certain place if tragedy strikes.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Nice
pacoundouriotis9 March 2017
Warning: Spoilers
Overall I did not like this film too much. It reminded a lot of a film we watched in the first semester called Ixcanul, another one I found rather unenteraining. From what I can recall about the first one, both of them were about arranged marriage and both of them had rather little dialogue. They were both pretty quiet films and followed the life of farmers. These films have almost a documentary approach to them. As far as the cinematography goes, they resemble each other a lot in my mind. There were a lot of scenes that were just very zoomed out and captured a lot of the bleak landscape that their countries contained. I can't remember much of the storyline of Ixcanul but this movie similarly followed the life of a female farmer named Tuya. Her husband ha sheen crippled and can't help her support their family. Tuya herself is later injured and is advised to stay away from intense manual labor to avoid further injury. Her husband divorces her and allows her to look for a husband that can surely support everyone in the family. She is caught between two suitors and the movie ends with both of them fighting and her leaving the scene. If I can remember correctly, in Ixcanul, the main character is also injured and later hospitalized. she is stuck with one suitor and is forced to marry him with no choice, whereas Tuya has some freedom in that she can select between two.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
Not the best foreign movie
sunnysarasota9 March 2017
Warning: Spoilers
This film was very different than most foreign films that I have seen. At most times during the film I was confused, because it would not really show what actually happened or what the results turned out being. The main character in the film Toya divorces Ba'toer, who then tries to commit suicide. This affects her and her children as well. Toya was in terms of conflict when deciding who her new husband would be. Even though she would be marrying someone else that man would have to promise to look after Ba'toer since he was need for medical care and did not have enough money himself, but many refused to do so. I think Toya wanted the best for Ba'toer after she left him, because he was still an important person to her, but I think she left him for the reason that he didn't have enough money to take care of herself and her children, that is why she goes and seeks for a wealthy man.I did not really like how the movie ended, because it never shows who she ends up being with, and I think this movie would have been better if things were clearer. However, I found it interesting how this film showed life in Mongolia, and this family was not very poor, like seen in most foreign films, they had a lot of animals, and lived in a house. Overall, I did not enjoy this film, as much as I thought I would have. The pacing was really slow, and many aspects of the film to me seemed bad, that is why I would rate this film a 2/5.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
fresh
Vincentiu3 September 2012
almost documentary. a woman in Inner Mongolia. her family. and her husband. a delicate situation. and one option. nothing else. result - a film about basic things in a isolated space. taste of sand and dust. a silent heroic existence. beauty of images. drops of humor. and sensation of a lot of pictures by strangers. very familiar pictures. a warm feeling, mixture of compassion and curiosity. a border film between testimony and art product. because the story is present in many movies from East. because the place, language or details are only pieces of a large arena.after its end, the flavor of savage beauty remains in memory. more than social postcard, it is trip in forms of human meetings as form of profound happiness.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
An error has occured. Please try again.

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed