Accident (2009) Poster

(2009)

User Reviews

Review this title
20 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
A Nutshell Review: Accident
DICK STEEL26 September 2009
Warning: Spoilers
You know how it is when you cry wolf too much, or are one of those pranksters who ultimately falls for a trick just because of you didn't believe it can happen to you. Accident plays along similar lines, and director Soi Cheang's latest film is an excellent atmospheric piece that adds to Milkyway's repertoire of tautly crafted contemporary crime thrillers.

Accident introduces a bunch of hit men who bump their marks off very differently. They are not hardened criminals who are on the radar of the cops, but operate in such stealthy fashion, from obtaining their contracts, right down to execution (pardon the pun) and retrieval of payment dues. The movie boasts two of such finely designed set action pieces sans guns ablazing, but full of meticulously planned cunning (in what is staple in heist films) carried out to a T, where death gets delivered to victims and made to look like freak acts of god, which of course takes a wee bit of stretching of the imagination since some bits do rely on coincidences to ensure a perfect degree of success.

The trouble amongst this group lies with the leader Brain (Louis Koo), whose crew consisting of Uncle (a welcome to see Feng Tsui-Fan back to the big screen), Fatty (a role that Milkyway evergreen regular Lam Suet owns), and a beautiful but unnamed woman (Michelle Ye), feel a little stifled given Brain's suspicious and paranoia nature. In what Brain preaches as Trust amongst his crew, it is actually trust that he personally doesn't embody, with frequent taps on his gang to ensure that they toe the line. The reason why Brain would choose a life as such was suggested in the prologue, which adds some emotional weight to the deliberate deadpan of the character, one conscientiously living off the grid, with no bank account, and no Octopus card too for public transport, preferring to use cash and not leave a paper trail.

It's the second half of the film that intrigued a lot more, as we're drawn into Brain's suspicious world from the time the second action sequence didn't go as planned, and went horribly awry. Refusing to believe in chance encounters since there are others in the business, and that their earlier victim had been a triad boss, we're thrusts into a web of possibilities to the chain of events that follow, which involves an insurance worker played by Richie Jen in what would be nothing more than a glorified cameo. You'll start to question whether Brain's set up from the inside (ala Brian De Palma's Mission Impossible), or is outwitted by Jen's character, or just drowning into his own delusions where his paranoia finally caught up with him.

And this became translated into the Louis Koo show. Of late he has been starring in a number of noteworthy roles, but his character here really took the cake. A friend of mine had commented that Lau Ching Wan would find the Brain character right up his alley, but I thought Koo did well enough in this role that involved minimal dialogue, of a quiet man on a warpath utilizing his trade to find some meaning in debunking that thing called Chance. I suppose you can also call it an occupational hazard of sorts.

The mood of the film will really get to you, with rain soaked sequences, moments of aloofness and loneliness (kinda like an art film at times too) and unflinching scenes of violence, with credit also going to the soundtrack by Xavier Jamaux, who has also been involved with and contributed to Milkyway productions such as Sparrow and Mad Detective. If you're a fan of the soundtrack from those movies, then you're in for a treat when you watch Accident.

Running less than 90 minutes, the finale, or the "Eureka" or moment of realization, is a scene that I'll remember for a long time to come. While it might have been similar to the Deux Ex Machina styled as employed in another Milkyway production in Eye in the Sky, I thought that it played into the themes of Chance, Fate and Karma all rolled into one perfectly shot and designed sequence, that had me at the edge of my seat and wondering how it would all finally play out. And when the answer is so starkly simple, you're left to ponder that you too have already become what Brain symbolized – you have thought too much, and share in the same level of reluctance to believe in anything other than the situation having to be something overly engineered.

I would recommend that you give Accident a go in the cinemas, but of course if you're willing to put up with it being dubbed in Mandarin, and censored sex scenes being treated in the same manner as Overheard.
32 out of 40 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
When the tables are turned, how can you be sure they have?
joebloggscity8 May 2010
I'm not sure what to make of this movie. It's not a long film, and so repeat viewings may make people appreciate its intricacies more. The film revolves around a small tight-knit group of assassins who work by killing their victims in ways that would appear to have been purely an accident, the "accident" being decidedly gruesome once executed.

Led diligently by a straight-forward highly intelligent man they call "Brains", they work to ensure no trace can lead the deaths to themselves. When the tables are turned and a member is killed, the focus closes on "Brain" who struggles to find out what has happened and gone wrong, and who is out to get them.

It's a moody film and uses the claustrophobic HK atmosphere well. One problem is that it's hard to decipher all that is happening from one viewing. It can get ponderous and confusing. The acting is generally very good and the action of the deaths very well done, but it doesn't compensate for the lack of clarity. Then again maybe it wasn't meant to be a tidy film and that is the point.

Overall, I thought it was okay and interesting enough. Maybe with some more work and time on the script then it could have become far better. Not bad, but just not great.
15 out of 19 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
6/10
Engrossing but Flawed Thriller
changmoh23 September 2009
Warning: Spoilers
FRESH from the Toronto International Film Festival 2009, this Johnny To-produced movie has all the marks of an art-house flick. It has no gun play, no martial art duels and not much in terms of fast-paced action. It is, however, thick with tension, intrigue and paranoia.

All these will probably work out to a short theatrical run, attended by art film lovers and Johnny To fans.

"Accident" offers up a 'new' kind of assassins for hire. Led by The Brain (Louis Koo), the four-member hit team choreographs intricate accidents on their targets. Since the deaths will invariably be classified by police as a freak accident ("death by misadventure"), they are off the authorities' radar. Indeed, the Brain is meticulous in his planning and his nameless partners, Uncle (Fung Shui-Fan), Fatty (Lam Suet) and Woman (Michelle Ye) are experts in their own fields.

However, when one of the 'accidents' goes terribly wrong, Brain suspects that someone is trying to kill him - and he sets his sights on Fong (Richie Jen), an insurance agent who happens to be on the accident scene.

Directed by Cheang Pou-Soi, "Accident" is a highly absorbing and engrossing crime thriller, especially in the first half. Here, we are fascinated by how the 'accidents' are planned and carried out, by the eccentricities of the individual members and, especially, the paranoia of Koo's character. With each sequence, Cheang manages to draw us deeper and deeper into his web of meticulous intrigue that seems to leave nothing to chance.

Things start to fall apart in the second half when Cheang transforms the movie into a psychological thriller - with the perpetrator believing that he has become the target. His fear and quest for revenge make him careless (scribbling plans on the ceiling) and callous, suspicious of even his own members. The movie's credibility starts to strain and what could have been a masterpiece is flawed. - By LIM CHANG MOH (limchangmoh.blogspot.com).
12 out of 15 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
totally watchable
thomas-chia0527 September 2009
if you like Johnnie's movies, this should be among your list remarkably, this movie is shot with only few characters but to an excellent portrayal not much talking with most of expression & meaning conveyed just by eye or facial movement

the curiosity & intense is able to get you focus through the entire movie unexpected death scenes much alike to the final destinations fame gives it extra entertainment

it's been quite some time we have enjoyed great hong Kong films since infernal affairs & exiled go watch it (definitely better than vengeance)
6 out of 20 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Good story and concept..!
kamalbeeee22 March 2021
A paid killer kills the target with the help of his team and make it looks like accident..at one stage he face the bad situation and tries to getrid of it.. Must watch movie..!!
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
10/10
Intriguing, original and simply astounding
moerchi22 September 2009
Accident might just be the most refined and intelligent piece of Hong Kong cinema since 2002's Infernal Affairs. The film probably won't prove as popular with mainstream audiences due to its almost meditative, slow-burn pacing - but for anyone with an interest in inventive genre cinema, Soi Cheang's newest outing is a must-see.

Taking its cues from Jean-Pierre Melville, Accident revolves around a group of assassins who stage their murders like accidents. The group is led by Brain (Louis Koo in a career-defining performance), who grows increasingly paranoid when one of the group's accidents goes awry and kills another member.

Thankfully, while the actual "accidents" are impressive and cleverly put together, Soi Cheang doesn't make the mistake of letting gimmicky set pieces dominate his film. Instead, Accident becomes a fascinating character study of a man who gradually destroys himself through paranoia and guilt. As such, the film largely depends on Louis Koo's performance - and what a performance it is; with this film, Koo finally deserves to be elevated from the hotpot of mediocre HK-popstars-cum-actors people used to include him in.

Add to this an elegiac score by Xavier Jamaux, elegant cinematography and you end up with the most compelling film to come out of Asia in the past 2 years.

If there is any problem to be found in this, it's that Accident is purely a Milkyway Image film, not a Soi Cheang film. Anyone hoping to find the director's trademark relentlessness here will be disappointed - although it could be argued some of the nihilism found in works like Dog Bite Dog was carried over into Accident's finale.
24 out of 39 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Thin
Hyomil16 November 2010
Accident's trailer gives a promising setup of a thriller focused on a team of assassins who make their killings look like accidents, but there's no follow through. Thrilling this is not, especially when you start to get into the grind of just how many niggling details have to be accounted for to make a death believable as an accident and how many things have to come together in the right way and at the right time or the whole thing has to be called off and back to the drawing board.

The movie might at least be intellectually interesting, but nothing is particularly believable or smart (the film is only capable of telling us Louis Koo's character is a genius rather than showing us) and there's minimal plot, dialog, or character interaction. Questions that should be asked aren't. Questions that no one really cares about are lingered on too long. Louis Koo plays the main character, Brain, dominating the screen time, and the disappearance of each of the other capable actors, none of whom are around for long, is keenly felt. I've seen Koo give some fine performances, but here he must spend most of the movie alone and silent, with no one to play off of, which is a tall order for any actor, even if they have a stellar script, which Accident most certainly does not. The silence also conveniently leaves out the need for the film to flesh out Brain's theories and what he's thinking and we're just left to guess--perhaps the director thought this would be a clever style because it would put the audience in the same mindset as the main character, but it just put me in the mindset of wanting to go to sleep.

With the main character being a stony hired killer, there's no one to root for, and it doesn't take too many lingering shots of Brain furrowing his brow to convey the wheels of his genius brain are turning while conducting surveillance of mundane events until you stop caring. Slogging through to the ending adds little, so you might as well just move on when the boredom gets intense. There's really not any "twist" at the end that redeems things, as some reviewers try to make out; I don't know if the film's creators really even intended there to be. If you're "blown away" by the ending, either you haven't seen many movies of this sort, or you should probably consider yourself a pretty thick.

Accident is just another triumph of atmosphere over substance that relies on cheap tricks to bypass viewers' ability to think critically about the weaknesses of the script by implying things that never materialize and various other manipulations that leave you feeling used at the end when it becomes apparent that the things you had to forgive in the hope that this was leading somewhere have led nowhere worth going. Overheard (2009), also with Koo (and Ching Wan Lau and Daniel Wu), comes to mind as an example of a better surveillance-themed movie.
13 out of 20 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Another underrated film on this website
ebossert28 July 2016
This film is underrated. Oh well, not every movie can be made by Marvel.

This film is about a professional hit-man and his team of self-styled "accident choreographers", who kill their victims by trapping them in well crafted "accidents" that look like unfortunate mishaps but are in fact perfectly staged acts of murder. He is consistently plagued by guilt, and the memories of his recently lost wife don't make things any easier. Even worse, one of his team members dies in an apparent "accident", which forces him to stay one step ahead of their competition.

One important thing that you need to understand about "Accident" is that it's a non-stop exhibition of paranoia because the scriptwriting is first-class as it straddles the line between chance and intent through a number of events that may signify an orchestrated murder by another party. The way this works is that some events are immediately shown to be acts of human intent – for example, the opening scene is clearly shown to be a murder that is made to look like an accident – but other events are left ambiguous, and you're not sure if it's an act of human intent or a moment of coincidence (or chance). So you're placed in the same situation as the protagonist because he's also not sure. And that's really the foundation of the entire movie, and it's a solid foundation to stand on.

It may be a surprise to you that the story moves slowly, but this could be considered a positive because it allows the paranoia to take center stage and it focuses a lot on developing the main character. The entire film revolves around this guy, making this just as much of a character piece as it is a series of suspense sequences. With that said, the "accidents" themselves are very cool and the direction is top notch. This was actually directed by Pou-Soi Cheang, and "Accident" was his best film in his filmography up to this point – representing an improvement over his previous titles. And I still think this is his best work, despite the fact that he has given us some very entertaining stuff between 2009 and the present day (such as "SPL 2: A Time for Consequences", "The Monkey King 2", and "Motorway").

The lead actor is Louis Koo, who earlier in his career appeared in a bunch of the "Troublesome Night" movies. Most fortunately, his roles subsequent to that franchise were far more reliable and entertaining. He's definitely an actor whose filmography is worth exploring because he's been in a lot of good movies. "Accident" is one of them, and I really liked his performance in this. It's a bit on the eccentric and gloomy side, but that's important for his character.

I definitely recommend "Accident", which is one of the better slow-burn suspense thrillers in recent memory. It is widely available on DVD, so be sure to check this one out.
8 out of 12 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Profoundly Idiotic
LeoXIV23 September 2010
Warning: Spoilers
I saw this movie at the Helsinki International Film Festival, more lovingly known as Love and Anarchy. The festival often caters to Johnnie To/Milkyway fans and this year we were "treated" to Accident.

This review contains major spoilers, so if you are interested in the film, I would suggest skipping this review. In short, i think this movie contains a near perfect story, but one of the worst scripts ever.

The story involves a group of contract killers that evade suspicion by staging elaborate murders that look like ACCIDENTS (Great premise). The group consists of four members: brain, fatty, uncle and an unnamed girl (Got to love these aliases, I mean who asks people to call them brain...a prick). The leader brain's wife (probably nicknamed heart, or perhaps the original fatty) died in a car crash which it would seem instigated brains contract killer lifestyle, and he seems to believe that the car crash was no mere ACCIDENT. The group get a contract to kill this innocent looking wheelchair-bound older dude (really uncool, btw). During the hit, something goes wrong and one of the group members gets killed, and brain is convinced this was no ACCIDENT either. Crazy times. This instigates the second part of the film, which focuses on brains operation to find out who set him up, killing his group member, listening to strangers have sex, murdering an innocent girl with the power of the sun, and getting killed himself. And for what? NOTHING! Yup, that's the big realization. Brain was a maniac, paranoid guy that saw figures in the shadows and great big schemes where there were none. Most likely this was his way to cope with the death of his wife, such a horrible act needed some rational reasoning, it could not be just an ACCIDENT. The idea that this guy was doomed by his own imagination and past experiences is just perfect. If this movie was remade by something like a Scorsese/DiCaprio collaboration they could really make something great. As it is....it's really bad. REALLY BAD.

You see the problem is that nearly every scene is unrealistic and thus unbelievable, and furthermore no character acts even semi-rationally, which makes the movie unconvincing and the characters meaningless. They are simply devices to advance an incredibly stupid script. OK, so brain is this intellectual mastermind that can orchestrate these insane domino effects, right? Then how is it, that he can't notice that one of his four members is clearly suffering from severe dementia. I mean so severe that he is popping pills at the rate of Tic Tacs. And the director makes the point of showing that brain is so careful not to leave any traces, paying with coins from a cloth and changing modes of transportation to loose any potential tails. Yet, still the guy is always right next to the murders, doesn't use gloves and leaves prints everywhere, makes the money drops in a parking lot with cameras (why?), the point being that clearly the character and script have not been developed very far. The best example of this are the murders. They are just too much based on chance. The first murder is just silly, the idea being that in the end there is a fallen banner that covers one fifth of the marks windshield, and for some reason instead of just driving past, he gets out and pulls the banner down, which results in a window breaking and the glass killing him. The one that just made everyone in the theater laugh was a murder that used a wet cord from a kite to transmit an electronic shock to the wheelchair-bound dude. I mean the idea that someone could predict how a kite would fly in a storm and where it would land is seriously idiotic. Anyway.

The other major issue is that this group is not sympathetic. They are contract killers with no redeeming features. From an ethical point, there is no reason for the audience to root for them, and the lack of a clear enemy through out most of the movie takes a lot of the potential tension away.

So all in all, the potential is there and I must say that I personally enjoyed watching the movie, just because it was so silly and unapologetic in its stupidity (the eclipse at the end, and that road sign...), so in a way this movie would rate 1 star based on script and 10 based on premise, hence the rating of 5.
13 out of 24 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Not Perfect, But Totally Worth The Watch!!
Movie-Misfit29 December 2019
With an intense score from Xavier Jamaux (who has done a few films for Milkyway Productions), and stunning cinematography from Edmond Fung - who incidentally shot the fantastic Dog Bite Dog, and Shamo, for director Cheang - you can't help but get drawn into the film, even with its slow-burning pace.

Accident is like watching a regular Johnnie To flick, but with an added darkness as director Soi Cheang harks back to his earlier films (mentioned above) to bring us an often intense, violent and dark thriller that - in my opinion - is quite underrated!

Louis Koo plays the Brain (literally) of a small but covert team of assassins who get paid to take out people, all while making it look like an accident. It may sound simple, but the team go to some lengths in their planning to pull of some convincing accidents that makes Death from Final Destination seem like a 60's Bond villain...

Of course, as a viewer, this means stretching the imagination a little as some of the plans rely on coincidences and chance to work. But not to a ridiculous degree, and of course at the end of the day - its just a film.

With some incredible, atmospheric night scenes in floods of rain, the film starts to take a turn for the worse as plans start to go wrong, and Brain's paranoia kicks in believing that he is now under threat - a victim to someone else's planning...

I don't want to give too much more away really, but Accident is most definitely worth the watch. Louis Koo gives a great performance as Brain, as does everyone else in their roles to be honest. It was great to see Stanley Fung (the Lucky Stars series) back in such a serious role. While he has been appearing in many films over the years, I definitely think this is one of his finest roles that saw him nominated for Best Supporting Actor at the 29th Hong Kong Film Awards.

While it may have its flaws and is not supposed to be the kind of film that leaves you feeling happy, Accident is well worth the watch and should definitely have gained more international attention with Hong Kong film fans!

Overall: A tense, atmospheric thriller, beautifully shot with an amazing score and performances from all involved!
2 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Good idea, average execution
Leofwine_draca19 December 2018
Warning: Spoilers
Another so-so thriller from Hong Kong, one with a fresh and interesting premise but lacking in sympathetic characters or decent direction to drive the story forward. What we're left with is a tale involving a murky team of assassins, working due to some past tragedy, whose method is to orchestrate bizarre 'accidents' to take down their victims. When one of their own number is killed, they begin an investigation into what exactly happened. This film boasts a good cast and some good set-piece accidents which are more than a little reminiscent of the blood-and-thunder of the FINAL DESTINATION franchise, but the rest is lacking. Louis Koo plays it stony-faced for the most part, although old-time comedy actor Stanley Fung is very good; the ubiquitous Lam Suet also makes an appearance.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Accident (2009)
SnakesOnAnAfricanPlain26 December 2011
Warning: Spoilers
A fantastic surprise. This movie I absolutely loved. I'd encourage you to get this without reading anymore on the topic. Still, here's my review. The film begins with a well shot scene involving lots of close- ups on the most mundane of objects. It's shot with a taste of suspicion. Imagine the death scenes in Final Destination and that's what we have here. A little more toned down than that but you should certainly have an open-mind for jumps in logic. Accident has the kind of high-concept plot that you'll find scattered around movie land. A gang of assassins makes their hits look like accidents, but it all goes pear shaped when an accident befalls the group themselves. Only, was it an accident. The nature of these assassins work leaves them paranoid and restless. The film is successful because it takes the mature route of exploring its themes. There is some action, but it gradually winds down into a more procedural spy type film. The main character is a man that has dealt with loss, and then dealt it out himself. He sees nothing as an accident, but are the recent events hostile acts against him, or just coincidences? Each action scene is marvelously underplayed, with minimalist-no music. By the time the final credits role I was emotionally exhausted and thoroughly entertained. A high-concept film, that requires both brains and letting some logic slide.
4 out of 6 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
1/10
accidents really do happen
orocolorado1 September 2012
This is the sort of movie I love if done right. I will say right off the bat this one is not done well. The premise is good = a gang of contract killers arrange murders to look like accidents. The leader of the gang gets trapped by his own paranoia forgetting that accidents can really do happen.

The murders reminded me of those serial action contraptions we had as kids that have one thing lead to another in a complicated sequence--a marble rolls down an incline to land on a lever that activates a spring that pours some water etc etc.....What ever happened to those toys? I guess computer games perempted them.

The idea is good why couldn't they have polished it up and made the thing believable? The murders are accomplished by unbelievably complicated serial actions that are just that UNBELIEVABLE---the first target gets out of his car because a canvas sign is covering part of the windshield (this is near the end of one of these unbelievable trip wire sequences)...why doesn't he just drive on? Better yet have the sign cover the whole windshield and make it believable!!! In another murder an old man in a wheel chair rolls down a street out of control to the exact spot where a wire is dangling from a high tension overhead power line---put there by a kite in a rain storm.

The visuals kind of sum up the caliber of the film....gory cheesy Kung Fu death sequences with watery blood belching out of mouths..

Over all plot where paranoia tricks the main character is also a good idea...but come on write a more convincing story--an eclipse of the sun ruining one of these things dumb! yawn!

Art Film Quality? You have to be kidding---well maybe not considering what wins at those things.

How is wish this movie had been better!

DO NOT RECOMMEND
4 out of 20 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Accident
Tweekums1 December 2023
This Hong Kong crime drama is centred on a group of assassins who specialise in murders that look like accidents. They are Ho Kwok-fai, aka 'The Brain'; 'Fatty'; 'The Woman' and 'Uncle'. So far these murders have never been suspected as anything other than accidents but they know that one mistake could lead to them all being investigated. Their latest job is carefully planned but something goes wrong... a bus careers out of control, just misses The Brain and kills Fatty. Was it just an accident or is somebody trying to eliminate The Brain using his own methods. He quickly become convinced that it is the latter. Is he paranoid or is somebody really out to kill him?

One might expect a Hong Kong crime drama to be full of martial arts, shooting and exciting chases; this is different though. It eschews such things, instead opting for a '70s style paranoid thriller where the protagonist isn't sure what is happening but still struggles to stop what might be happening. This approach keeps the tension high as we don't know who can be trusted. Mostly it is gripping but one does occasionally have to suspend ones disbelief... solar eclipses are not surprise events they can be predicts centuries in advance! The cast is solid; I especially liked Louis Koo's performance as The Brain. Overall I'd certainly recommend this to fans of Hong Kong films looking for something a bit different.

These comments are based on watching the film in Cantonese with English subtitles.
1 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
2/10
Incredibly Stupid
ashwin-ramaswamy12 December 2018
This movie is so stupid, I just had to write a review. Enough has been said, so I'll just add this : One of the final scenes in the movie involves a sudden (yes, sudden) Total Solar Eclipse which everyone looks at with delightful joy with bare naked eyes... And even take pics with their smartphones and call other loved ones who are busy shopping across the street even while the Total Solar Eclipse turns day into night. The movie has so much more brilliant stupidity, it's worth me giving it more than 1*
2 out of 8 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Cause and Effect
sospensionedelgiudizio12 February 2012
If every effect is the son of the cause and every cause is simply the inescapable track towards it, then what is an accident? Is there really a possibility that the events in this world can move without direction, without any puppeteer, at no charge? Brain does not believe in chance. His wife died in a car accident with no apparent responsible and to believe in coincidences would mean to give up any why. Uncle, Fatman and Woman are other accomplices (no other specific name will be given) with which the brain, for a fee, plan very complex human models that transmute a murder into what seems nothing more than an accident. When the organization clashes with the unexpected death of Fatman during the staging of a difficult job, then something clicks in Brain, who betrayed his illusion of total control of human events, begins to investigate on the event becoming suspicious of his own friends. Paranoia, revenge and mirror games become the ingredients of the investigation against those who would have sabotaged the puppet theater of which he is a betrayed deus ex machina and will accompany us to a final resolution (that is one of the best things about this movie). Soi Cheang is part of the team of Johnny To and the new Hong Kong cinema. The Chinese city is perpetually shrouded in an aura of inhuman and sometimes sterile suspension. Violence erupts as is, without too much indulgence and without any cutting. The intricate accident sequences are thrilling in their complexity and streaked here and there by a certain poetry. The rain, the neon lights and a solar eclipse dusty become the dominant hue of the photography. We can think Brain not as a criminal, but a sort of artist who paints on a canvas the instruction book of human-robot who thinks he can choose, who thinks things randomly happen to him, who thinks he's really living.

Giovanni Cassanese www.kayfa.be
2 out of 5 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
5/10
Unexpected and Insipid
kampolam-7581315 October 2022
Warning: Spoilers
Soi Cheang Pou-Soi has always been regarded as a director with personality and style. In fact, this is an assistant director, in terms of mastering the production process and controlling the scene, these are the strengths of these "red pants" (Red pants is a Hong Kong slang term referring to the grassroots personnel in the workplace. The allusions come from the actors of the Cantonese Opera Troupe) directors. And Soi Cheang once mentioned in an interview why he had the urge to run to be a director back then, because he met Wilson Yip Wai-Shun, which made him understand the key to creation, and followed him to make his first self-directed film "Diamond Hill" (2000). Later, he was highly valued by Joe Ma Wai-Ho and began to conceive a unique horror film. Among them, "Big Head Monster" (2001) showed the skill of mastering the horror atmosphere and effect. Unfortunately, the script pattern is too large and uncontrollable, which greatly reduces the overall performance. Since then, Soi Cheang has formed an indissoluble bond with horror films, and the "blood" relationship described in his films has become the style of his films, and many film critics have developed and discussed this theme.

"Accident" (2009) is a film co-produced by Soi Cheang and Johnnie To Kei-Fung. In fact, Soi Cheang has participated in Johnnie To's films as early as the Cinema City period, and in the "Triangle" (2007) co-directed by Hark Tsui, Ringo Lam Ling-Tung and Johnnie To, Soi Cheang was appointed by Ringo Lam as his assistant director, Soi Cheang has long been highly valued in the industry as an assistant director. As for "Accident", it can be said to be Soi Cheang's most complete work so far. The film centers on a group of professional killers who commit murder by creating accidents. In fact, the film only has two carefully designed "accident" murders. In the first act, the audience is still in the dark, experiencing the murder trap set by Louis Koo Tin-Lok; then, the audience follows the process of how they design the trap, and at the same time they encounter an accident, which makes their original mutual suspicion relationship turbulent. This time, Soi Cheang focused on the details of the film and the psychological state of the characters, instead of focusing on the complexity of the story and plot. Although the story of the film is quite thin, in the screenwriter's term, it is called "one big idea to the end", which is obviously the producer. The adjustments Johnnie To made are similar to the films he directed, and the sudden and unexpected results of the ending or surprises the audience.

This adjustment has indeed made this film Soi Cheang's most complete work, but it is also one of the dullest of his films. In addition, the ending is almost an art film, which fails to give the audience a kind of satisfaction in watching the film. In particular, the role of Richie Jen Hsien-Chi, with his tricks and tricks, makes the audience feel discouraged, not as bright and moving as Soi Cheang's past films. In addition, many actors in the film performed well, especially the old actors Stanley Fung Tsui-Fan and Michelle Ye Xuan, etc. And the two leading actors, Louis Koo and Richie Jen were able to cope with such difficult performances. The film still has a plot where the son buys the murderer, continuing Soi Cheang's theme of blood relationship.

By Kam Po LAM (original in Chinese)
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Awesome film
jacquesdelyons28 November 2020
Really cool shot sequences that play with the central character's paranoia. Engaging story and character arch that explores the power of illusion and confusion in the human mind. Way better than Shawshank Redemption.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Not really impressed with this one...
paul_haakonsen5 March 2020
I hadn't heard about this 2009 Hong Kong movie named "Accident" (aka "Yi ngoi") before I stumbled upon in here in 2020. Needless to say that with my interest and fascination with the Hong Kong cinema, I needed no persuasion to sit down and watch the movie.

Turns out that "Accident" wasn't much of an outstanding movie. Why? Well, the storyline just failed to really sink its hook in me. I never really felt fully immersed in the storyline as it felt rushed and just too simplistic for me.

Little did it help that all the characters in the movie were essentially one and the same, as they had little or no distinctive personalities or traits, so they could effectively have been portrayed by one and the same actor or actress. And the fact that the movie had the likes of Louis Koo, Richie Jen and Suet Lam on the cast list and still failed to be interesting, well... I will chalk it up to some really lousy writing and character development.

For a Hong Kong movie, then "Accident" failed to leave a lasting impression and it was a less than mediocre movie experience as a whole. I just felt that the story was half-hearted and missing very crucial elements to make it a more enjoyable and enriching movie experience.

I am rating "Accident" a mere four out of ten stars. And I can in all honesty say that this is not a movie that I will be watching a second time around.
0 out of 1 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
Coincidence(?)
kosmasp4 April 2023
No pun intended - watching this may make you question everyday stuff. Or things in general ... is all being manipulated and orchestrated? Will the movie give a definitive answer to that? Will you become a conspiracy follower? Well hopefully not ... but also hopefully you will enjoy this. It is a movie after all - there is a heightened feeling all around.

And with the great actors it has at hand and at disposal ... well it really does work nicely. There is one event that kicks off ... the rest of the movie. But the beginning itself is quite something ... again the idea is intriguing. Hopefully you are open to movies outside the US/Hollywood pond ... or whatever you want to call it. If you are, you probably already know that a lot of really good movies come from all around the world.

And if you don't mind the moral "issues" the movie has (do not try this at home or wherever "accidents" can happen) ... remember this is just a movie ... a very good one at that.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed