Roses Gate (2022) Poster

(2022)

User Reviews

Review this title
2 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
8/10
Better than most of us will ever know
Nozz19 April 2023
My wife loved this one... but she knows a little Morocccan Arabic, and part of the film's appeal is nostalgia for the family life of Moroccan immigrants to Israel. Several language consultants are credited, and I'm assured that the language, like the customs, is vividly and amusingly recreated. I have to say a lot of it passed me by, and apparently that goes for much of the population. At a morning showing a couple of weeks after this film premiered, the two of us were alone in the auditorium.

Parts of the film, particularly near the beginning, come across rather like a stage play as members of a large family sit around trading colorful remarks. The film does remind us increasingly with visuals, though, that we're in a poor desert town, presumably Sderot.

A young member of the family likes to videotape everyone else. Such a device can be a warning sign-- a sign that the screenwriter can think of no other way for the characters to speak their minds, or that he can't write a story that isn't about himself-- but in this case it's just a quirk and the family is remarkably capable of ignoring the videocamera until it gets to be too much for them.

It's not always easy to remember who fits in where, but we come to accept that the main character is the one played by popular TV actor Arik Mishali. He's a compulsive gambler, and he's menaced by a debt collector who, for some unaccountable reason, speaks only in English. That arc seems to conclude early, yielding place to a couple of rather rushed love stories, but there are surprises yet to come before the end. I suppose the structure of the script is what sets it apart from other family-centered Israeli comedy/dramas. That, and a praiseworthy reluctance to emphasize strident caricature.
0 out of 2 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
8/10
Same culture different religion.
fadielsane-461613 June 2024
The movie was really interesting from the perspective of an arab.

The older cast did a really good preformance, however the camera, and the younger people where like robots. That being said, the movie, for me, showsa comparison between the bedouins and the marrocans who are living in the Negev.

It shows the struggle of pepole who came to israel and didn't know better.

Nevertheless, going to university is very easy in israel, just get the right grades. Providing you go to a nice school, or just be part of a minority.

All in all israel is not a place you want to raise your kid.

Its an evil place full with hate.
0 out of 0 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed