"It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia" McPoyle vs. Ponderosa: The Trial of the Century (TV Episode 2016) Poster

User Reviews

Review this title
4 Reviews
Sort by:
Filter by Rating:
10/10
The Magnum Opus of IASIP.
michaelaasuquo2 November 2021
This is the best episode of It's Always Sunny I've seen. You know when something is so funny that your stomach hurts from laughing too hard? And then something happens right after that that makes you laugh even harder? Imagine having that feeling for 17 straight minutes. The best thing this episode does is utilize multiple running gags better than any show has in a single episode. And these aren't the most important gags. These are smaller gags that you probably forgot about like Jack's hands and Maureen being a cat.

After season 2 I never thought this show would hit that level of comedy again. This is episode somehow surpassed that. The writes and performers outdid themselves this episode. Take a bow!
17 out of 22 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
9/10
I can't believe after 11 seasons this show is still this GREAT!
dcarvalhogarcia13 September 2020
Warning: Spoilers
I started watching It's Always Sunny recently, and considering the show has 14 seasons I was expecting the show to drop in quality at some point. However, I was completely wrong, here I am at season 11 and the episodes are still incredible! In this episode, we finally see the consequences of this show's "Red Wedding" in the form of a lawsuit against Bill Ponderosa, and we get to see the craziness of both the Ponderosa family and the McPoyles! Plus, we finally get a payoff for Charlie's "Bird Law" that he talks so much about, and (SPOILERS) the fact that it pretty much wins the case was hilarious! The creativity of the creators of the show impresses me so much, and that's why I wanted to leave this review :)
20 out of 27 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
7/10
Always Sunny jumping the shark here
rhemfelt125 September 2020
Warning: Spoilers
The episode was just too zany and over the top for me. Pretty much every side character is ramped up into a Scooby Doo-like character, and previously established character quirks are escalated beyond what is even remotely entertaining (to me).

I loved the Pondy side story with his kid though.

If you're into their courtroom episodes and slapstick humor then you'll probably love this episode. It's just not for me.
11 out of 42 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink
4/10
Far too eccentric for this show
i-am-so-original18 February 2016
Warning: Spoilers
Let me be up front and Frank about this. This episode was trash. Unbearable, reprehensible, borderline unwatchable trash. I hated practically every second of it, and it's a further argument towards Sunny's vast and sharp decline in quality over the last couple of years, but particularly this season.

The episode revolves around the McPoyles suing the Ponderosas for spiking the milk bowl at their wedding with bath salts or some crap like that. Really, it's just an excuse for wacky characters to be in the same room and do wacky things. And by wacky, I mean terribly unfunny things.

The episode starts, and immediately hits a dead end. Uncle Jack is now wearing gigantic plastic hands because he's insecure about his tiny limbs. It's a dumb joke. At one point, the hand flies off into the crowd, and he screams to everyone about not looking as he hides his real hand to retrieve his fake one. Hilarious stuff.

But what gets me is how absolutely insane and outlandish Sunny has become. The episode features Maureen dressed and acting like a cat, complete with freaky contacts and long nails. She proceeds to actually rub her face on the judge's stand and chases a laser beam around the room. Are you kidding me?

Oh, Benicio Del Toro shows up with a bird in his hat and orders it to attack the prosecuting lawyer, where it proceeds to tear his eye out (or something. Either way he had a bandage).

Sunny has always gone to some far out places, but this is something else entirely. This is not a show where humans turn into cats, lawyers wear insanely large fake hands, and birds attack people. That's the stuff you'd find in a cartoon, and despite Sunny occasionally venturing into absurd territory, this is full blown bizarre, and it doesn't work.

The episode had a few occasional chuckles. Charlie's constant berating of Jack was funny, and Dee's public outrage about the lawyer being Jewish was particularly hurtful and offensive, which is always a plus.

It's painfully obvious that the core three behind the show (Howerton, Day, McElhenney) have lost interest and/or time. Their names only appear once in the writing credits for the entire season (the premiere, and even then, Howerton is absent), and their roles have been painfully diminished. Instead of the brilliant writing and back and forth between the characters, they've been sidelined, and we're left with preposterous and untrue eccentricities, and that is not something that I tune in to Sunny for.

Grade: F

For more reviews, head over to nathansharp28.wordpress.com.
11 out of 167 found this helpful. Was this review helpful? Sign in to vote.
Permalink

See also

Awards | FAQ | User Ratings | External Reviews | Metacritic Reviews


Recently Viewed