I remember liking this movie. I first saw it many years ago (15-20?). Granted, I was very young and I think I watched just the second half but still, I had high expectation for this rewatch. And oh boy, I did not expect this.
Firstly, the acting. Honestly, it's not great. It's not all bad. But there are some scenes when the actors just aren't doing a good job. They feel "fake". They sound "fake". They act unconvincingly. And there was a particular scene when I wondered "why is this feeling like a parody? Why is he smiling in this context? It makes no sense"
Secondly, the story. What I did like was his friendship with the black inmate. Highlight of the movie.
However, I don't like how the movie showed how and why he got tempted by nazism in the first place. I'm not American and I don't live in USA. But I think it's wrong and frankly patronizing and preachy to imply that immigration without legal documents should be allowed and that anyone who disagrees with it is spewing nazi talk. This retoric is downright mindbogling. I get that the movie maybe tries to suggest that real problems atract evil "solutions", that the road to hell is paved by good intentions but still, it didn't came that way. It turned out more in the sense of "everyone I don't like is literally Hitler".
And perhaps the worst thing of them all is the suggestion that Derek stopped being a nazi because the inmates didn't truly believe in their ideology. Really, movie? This is what you are going for? This is what made Derek to be disillusioned with nazism? Not the fact that he befriended a black guy? That he finally saw how evil and wrong nazism truly is? Did he ever understand how nazism is hurting innocent people? His trigger point was the fact no one in prison was as devoted to the cause as him. Unbelievable bad. He got upset with nazism because he was r.aped? This is the solution suggested by the movie?
Also, the ending is bad. Danny didn't get killed because he was turning into a nazi. He got killed because he previously got into an altercation with a gang member. So what's the "lesson" here? To never stand up against a thug? If anything, this movie suggest that Danny was right in the first place. Which is crazy, in trying to convert an anti-nazi message, the movie managed to do the opposite.
Now that I'm thinking about it, I'm actually considering if I should lower the rating, to a 5 at least.
In conclusion, there are better anti-nazi movies. This isn't one of them. Watch "The Pianist" instead. Or even better, go watch a documentary.
Firstly, the acting. Honestly, it's not great. It's not all bad. But there are some scenes when the actors just aren't doing a good job. They feel "fake". They sound "fake". They act unconvincingly. And there was a particular scene when I wondered "why is this feeling like a parody? Why is he smiling in this context? It makes no sense"
Secondly, the story. What I did like was his friendship with the black inmate. Highlight of the movie.
However, I don't like how the movie showed how and why he got tempted by nazism in the first place. I'm not American and I don't live in USA. But I think it's wrong and frankly patronizing and preachy to imply that immigration without legal documents should be allowed and that anyone who disagrees with it is spewing nazi talk. This retoric is downright mindbogling. I get that the movie maybe tries to suggest that real problems atract evil "solutions", that the road to hell is paved by good intentions but still, it didn't came that way. It turned out more in the sense of "everyone I don't like is literally Hitler".
And perhaps the worst thing of them all is the suggestion that Derek stopped being a nazi because the inmates didn't truly believe in their ideology. Really, movie? This is what you are going for? This is what made Derek to be disillusioned with nazism? Not the fact that he befriended a black guy? That he finally saw how evil and wrong nazism truly is? Did he ever understand how nazism is hurting innocent people? His trigger point was the fact no one in prison was as devoted to the cause as him. Unbelievable bad. He got upset with nazism because he was r.aped? This is the solution suggested by the movie?
Also, the ending is bad. Danny didn't get killed because he was turning into a nazi. He got killed because he previously got into an altercation with a gang member. So what's the "lesson" here? To never stand up against a thug? If anything, this movie suggest that Danny was right in the first place. Which is crazy, in trying to convert an anti-nazi message, the movie managed to do the opposite.
Now that I'm thinking about it, I'm actually considering if I should lower the rating, to a 5 at least.
In conclusion, there are better anti-nazi movies. This isn't one of them. Watch "The Pianist" instead. Or even better, go watch a documentary.
Tell Your Friends